> >


Michael O'Toole's Restaurant



89 E Nationwide Blvd
Columbus, OH 43215

View more Columbus restaurants

(614) 586-4585

  • Sun - Closed;
  • Mon - Sat 11:00am - 2:00am

Cuisine: Irish Restaurants

View more restaurants at exit 100b on I-70.


4.3 of 5.0 from 29 reviews


price range:$26 to $50

Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free


Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH
  • Michael O'Toole's Restaurant in Columbus, OH

Blogger Reviews of Michael O'Toole's Restaurant

  • Tree's Kitchen on Aug 20, 2013

    Well, I'm still recovering from last weekend. We took a road trip to Columbus, OH to go to Rock on the Range, a 2 day concert...

    View Full Review

Read more blogger reviews in Columbus

Add your blog review!



Do you own a business and need a way to monitor your reviews across all sites, not just Foodio54? ReviewSnoop is offering a free trial to monitor your reviews and photos across dozens of review sites.

Michael O'Toole's Restaurant Reviews

Add your review for Michael O'Toole's Restaurant.

  • Kevin Z.AMAZING! Great food. Amazing Service. Can't recommend this place more!

    55555 by Kevin Z.


  • Nicholas T.The "Shot in the Dark" cocktail is great and the baked oysters and scallops on the app menu are tasty

    55555 by Nicholas T.


  • Ken H.Try the scallops, they're amazing!

    55555 by Ken H.


  • Aaron W.Meh. Nothing great or bad about this place. Just so so.

    33333 by Aaron W.


  • Shane H.The filet is surprisingly good

    55555 by Shane H.


  • Joseph W.If you can make it for Restaurant Week go!

    55555 by Joseph W.


  • TeeJayEverything we had was excellent. From out of town and happened across this place. Excellent find.

    55555 by TeeJay


  • Jaclyn E.This place sucks! The food was terrible & the staff was creepy.

    11111 by Jaclyn E.


  • 89 F.try the calamari with the shot in the dark for a tasty appetizer! http://www.columbusalive.com/content/stories/2012/04/05/happy-hour-89-fish--grill.html

    55555 by 89 F.


  • 89 F.What's fresh? yellowfin tuna oscar topped with crabmeat and bernaise and served with asparagus and mashed potatos

    55555 by 89 F.


  • Ruth R.The fish tacos are excellent!! Finally a good restaurant in this location...

    55555 by Ruth R.


  • FayeTry the Shot in the Dark - Bulleit, balsamic reduction, basil & lime. Delicious!

    55555 by Faye


  • Ashley S.Had the grilled scallops, they were amazing! Also loved our waitress. She was so lovely without trying too hard.

    55555 by Ashley S.


  • D M.Had the simply grilled salmon medium rare. Perfect!

    55555 by D M.


  • Christine I.Perfect atmosphere, wine list and I couldn't eat enough of the oysters!!

    55555 by Christine I.


  • Cookie M.The tuna tartare is addictive! Delish!

    55555 by Cookie M.


  • Amy H.It's closed for good.

    33333 by Amy H.


  • Heather N.If u want to eat.. don't come here

    33333 by Heather N.


  • Karl C.Meters now accept credit and debit cards

    33333 by Karl C.


  • Britain G.The waitresses are AWESOME.

    55555 by Britain G.


  • Jessie$5 burger & beer combo from 4-7 during home Clippers Games

    55555 by Jessie


  • Michael O.Thirsty Dog is now on tap.

    55555 by Michael O.


  • FergBeer is pretty warm. (not sure why)

    33333 by Ferg


  • FergDon't get the crab legs, very over priced for the serving size.

    22222 by Ferg


  • Michael O.$5 Burger & Brew for Columbus Blue Jackets HOME games exclusively in the bar area from 4-7pm.

    55555 by Michael O.


  • Kayne K.Get the fries. Kettle chips are just ok.

    33333 by Kayne K.


  • Michael O.Michael O'Toole's is having a party after the OSU game this Saturday (9/11/10) $4 Hurricanes and $4 Sex w/ an Alligator shots

    55555 by Michael O.


  • JessieTry the O'Toole's Amber Ale. A perfect draft beer.

    55555 by Jessie


  • Bruce C.Bring plenty of quarters if u use meters to park

    55555 by Bruce C.


Nearby Restaurants