Looking for romantic restaurants for Valentine's Day?
Harry and Izzy's
153 S. Illinois St
Indianapolis, IN 46225
View more Indianapolis restaurants
- Sunday: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
- Monday: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
- Tuesday: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
- Wednesday: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
- Thursday: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
- Friday: 11:00 am - Midnight
- Saturday: 11:00 am - Midnight
View more restaurants at exit 111 on I-65.
4.8 of 5.0 from 56 reviews
price range:$26 to $50
Is this your restaurant? Claim Your Listing
Harry and Izzy's Reviews
Seared tuna was excellent.
by Noah S.
The mashed potatoes are amazing! A must get side to accompany a great steak.
by Antwan M.
AMAZING. Everything. Favorite dessert: the sugar creme pie. Oh. My. God.
by Caitlin F.
Order the shrimp cocktail and prepare for a nasal awakening. Incredible cocktail sauce, second to none!
by Mark C.
Sean is an awesome server!
by emily c.
Filet sliders... Just do it.
by Teresa H.
STEAKBURGER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nuff said!
by Josh W.
Awesome Food. Went for the Devour Downtown. Hi to the best server Jo!!! What fun we had
by Anna M.
The blackened catfish was great...spicy but awesome!!!
by India J.
Shrimp cocktail horseradish very hot!!""
by Michael B.
Great food and apparently owned by a louisville cardinal fan. Stopped by after louisville's win over duke.
by John M.
You don't make a trip to Indianapolis without hitting up either St. Elmo's or Harry & Izzy's. You just don't. It's like a law or something.
by NBA G.
St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail is bombs. Just be prepared to blow fire out your ass the next day!
by Paul B.
Good food for the price
by Terrell M.
Shrimp cocktail is very good but it it will knock you on your butt lol
by Jeremiah A.
Their mashed potatoes are heavenly !
by Chelcie J.
Ask for the shrimp cocktail sauce to be served on the side. The sauce is so hot in flavor that it literally ruins the beautiful shrimp they have flown in, and I'm not a whimp!
by Dewey H.
Don't get the fried green tomato sandwich. Mush.
by Andrew K.
Really good. Enjoy steak sandwich.
by john r.
New York Strip, sure!!!!!!
by Paulo M.
If you go for lunch... don't ask for menus simply listen to me. You will want the lunch special. For $20. Only $20 gets you the signature shrimp cocktail, filet sliders with soup, and dessert.
by Jared F.
If you don't get the filet mignon, you are missing out!
by Eric N.
The booth seats sound really awesome as a drum.
by Michelle M.
Great menu, I loved the fried green tomatoes and the smoked pork chops
If I could "Izzy style" my hand, I'd probably eat it too.
by Christopher H.
Eating meat is overrated! Get the Beet Salad! It's dynamite!
by Mr P.
Try the Izzy Style Ny Strip - Great cut. Usually don't like sauces on my steak, but this is truly unique. (via @Foodspotting)
by Chris P.
Try the Shrimp Cocktail - My sinuses jumped, screaming from my face. Tons of horseradish. Awesome. (via @Foodspotting)
by Chris P.
They're FREE? Check-IN http://bit.ly/Q2L9Te for @HARTheatre Shakespeare on Canal @WhiteRiverStPrk| OTHELLO 7/20-7/22! #WRSP #ArtMatters http://inwhiteriver.com
by WINDY W.
Prime Rib sandwich is amazing!
The Shrimp Cocktail is insane! So hot its dinner and a show.
by Jacob S.
Possibly the best fish 'n chips in town. Hard to bring myself to get them when there's such an epic prime rib sandwich on the same menu, though.
by Sean M.
Best prime rib sandwich ever conceived.
by Sean M.
Try their Fried Green Tomatoes... one of my favorites when I am in town!
by Lindsay N.
Ask for Craig as your server!
by Jules M.
Prime rib sammy was great!
by Doug W.
Don't eat here, food is over priced and not all that spectacular!!!
by Gary V.
The St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich is on the Super 46 Sandwiches
by David B.
Steakburger was money
by Jeremy F.
Try the tenderloin samdwich.
by Phil S.
Check out Georgia Street now that they have finished. The city has really done it up for the Super Bowl.
by Scott V.
Try their bloody Mary featuring locally-produced Hoosier Momma Bloody Mary Maker. Best you'll have anywhere!
by Stephen E.
The tomato mozzarella salad and spicy Asian shrimp appetizer are delicious!!
by Erin L.
You can't go wrong with the Downtown Pizza, the Calamari, or the Steakburger....
by Emory E.
Fillet slides are to die for!
by April W.
Steaks are great and definitely try the slab of cheese cake!! And ask for Cedric great server :-)
by Kari B.
This is on my must do list in Indy. The shrimp cocktail is out of this world! Be prepared for sinus-gripping pain!
by Alison C.
Great New York strip!
by Steve K.
by Nikki J.
The garbage salad is a must! Plenty of meat but because of the green stuff you can claim you're eating healthy. Order the half if you're having it with a meal - trust me!
by Alicia H.
Gotta get the shrimp cocktail!
by Alli N.
The shrimp cocktail will rock your world!
by Stacy H.
Burgers r titlicious
If you are trying to decide between this place and its brother next door. Go with St. Elmos.
by Greg F.
Izzy style New York strip and Tuscan pasta are both fantastic, and Cedric ( our waiter ) was phenomenal
by Bryan S.
Mikado Japanese Restaurant & Sushi
148 South Illinois Street
Ram Restaurant Big Horn Brewery Indianapolis
140 South Illinois Street
St Elmo Steak House - Restaurant
127 South Illinois Street
25 West Georgia Street
Severin Bar and Grille
40 West Jackson Place
123 South Illinois Street
California Pizza Kitchen
49 Maryland St #104
245 McCrea St
Bee Coffee Roasters
201 S Capitol Ave #110
Pullman's Restaurant & Bar
123 West Louisiana Street