Looking for restaurants open on Christmas?

> >


The Old Fashioned



23 North Pinckney Street
Madison, WI 53703

View more Madison restaurants

(608) 310-4545

Cuisine: American Restaurants


4.7 of 5.0 from 219 reviews

Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free


The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI
  • The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI

The Old Fashioned Reviews

Add your review for The Old Fashioned.

  • Traveler5546 reviewA retro supper club with Wisconsin oriented menu; well worth trying at least once.

    55555 by Traveler5546


  • Igal G.Came here to compare cheese curds, Graze wins by a mile

    55555 by Igal G.


  • Ben B.Drink a beer made in Wisconsin. It's all they have!

    55555 by Ben B.


  • Daniel LThe burger was one of the best I've ever had. The imperial stout was also a great compliment to the burger.

    55555 by Daniel L


  • LilitThe "imported" beer is from Minnesota.

    55555 by Lilit


  • Lauren LI got the No. 32 bratwurst and it was so amazing! The brats had great flavor and the fries were delicious, in addition to their great root beer!

    55555 by Lauren L


  • Tom SLazy Susan #6 perfect accompaniment with a Bourbon Old Fashioned

    55555 by Tom S


  • Michael MBest cheese curds and great fish sandwich

    55555 by Michael M


  • PureWowIf there’s one state that knows its mac and cheese, it’s Wisconsin. The Old Fashioned cooks its version on the stovetop, then bakes it with bread crumbs at the last minute for added crunch.

    55555 by PureWow


  • Diane ZHad to have an Old Fashioned of course, very good! Also there's so many beers

    55555 by Diane Z


  • Diane ZCheese curds, Mac and cheese, cherry and gorgonzola salad

    55555 by Diane Z


  • Pixoy RPide los Cheese Curds y la Egg Burger

    55555 by Pixoy R


  • Ben SCheese curds were great! The reuben (special) was really tasty. Definitely try an old fashioned, the signature brandy cocktail.

    55555 by Ben S


  • Lee S.Great selection of Wisconsin craft beer along with locally influenced pub grub, cheese curds are a must!

    55555 by Lee S.


  • Paul DBloody Mary's and all the food!

    55555 by Paul D


  • Gregory S.Great beer selection, great food. Love their cheese curds. The French dip sandwich is really nice.

    55555 by Gregory S.


  • Robinson PThe fish sandwich was amazing!

    55555 by Robinson P


  • Rami DFried cheese curds are very tasty

    55555 by Rami D


  • Alice F.Try the Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet - The quintessential Wisconsin drink. (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Alice F.


  • Kate Y.CHEESE CURDS OBVIOUSLY.

    55555 by Kate Y.


  • Ally ACheese curds are a MUST!!

    55555 by Ally A


  • Hikaru ABurguer ... Amazing !!!

    55555 by Hikaru A


  • Clarasssauruswednesday night karaoke!

    55555 by Clarasssaurus


  • Joe PachalGood Wisconsin beers, fish frys, and of course old fashioneds

    55555 by Joe Pachal


  • Dylan E.Friendliest bartender I have ever encountered.

    55555 by Dylan E.


  • Michal JQuarter if the apple fritter was more than sufficient. It's huge! Great atmosphere right on the square.

    55555 by Michal J


  • Mark JExtensive beer list, great curds. Try the Summer Sausage sandwich!

    55555 by Mark J


  • Andrew L.Legit cheese curds

    55555 by Andrew L.


  • Keith AEverything is incredible here! A great place with awesome food all from Wisconsin. Get something with Neuske's bacon on it and dip your fries in the Tiger Sauce.

    55555 by Keith A


  • Alyssa JOld fashions and curds

    55555 by Alyssa J


  • Todd M.Burgers, greasy cheese curds, fun dipping sauces and Wisconsin beer.

    55555 by Todd M.


  • Kate WCheese curds, drinks, authentic Wisconsin food

    55555 by Kate W


  • Rick HMassive beer selection and some pretty good food.

    55555 by Rick H


  • kailey BCheese curds !!!!

    55555 by kailey B


  • Nicholas JThe beer list is, in a word, extensive. Before you start browsing, get an order of cheese curds in. By the time you've chosen a drink, your food will arrive.

    55555 by Nicholas J


  • Nicholas JBeer #27 is perfect for raspberry lovers.

    55555 by Nicholas J


  • Tracy C.Cheese curds are amazing! Burgers are great. Old fashion and brandy slush were fantastic, too! Can't go wrong here.

    55555 by Tracy C.


  • CorinnePurchase the Saturday Farmers' Market special drink and $1 will be donated to charity of the month. Plus, you get an entry into their meat raffle

    55555 by Corinne


  • Katie Milliken2-for-1 rail mixers and beers after 10 Tuesday-Thursday and sometimes on Monday! Karaoke on Wednesdays!

    55555 by Katie Milliken


  • RyanCHEESE CURDS

    55555 by Ryan


  • JessicaTry the flights!

    55555 by Jessica


  • Daniel A#30 house burger

    33333 by Daniel A


  • Marty O.Call ahead for reservations. Always packed

    55555 by Marty O.


  • Jeremy H.Great cheese curds. Staff are friendly which is great after the long wait.

    55555 by Jeremy H.


  • Jared WickHave a sweet whisky old fashion with your fish tacos.

    55555 by Jared Wick


  • Ryan TSpicy burger and cheese curds!

    55555 by Ryan T


  • Paul Rossmaneverything! yes, everything!

    55555 by Paul Rossman


  • Stephen W.Great selection of local craft beers

    55555 by Stephen W.


  • Miles H.Cheese curds outta this world!

    55555 by Miles H.


  • Minh N.Brats and cheese curls!

    55555 by Minh N.


  • Aaron RCheese curds!! The burgers are amazing too!! I absolutely love this place! The atmosphere, the workers, everything is great!!

    55555 by Aaron R


  • Dustin F.Bucky don't care!

    33333 by Dustin F.


  • John W.Really? Cheese Curds, old fashions, everything! Greatest thing since sliced bread!

    55555 by John W.


  • Corinne#30 is one of the messiest burgers I've ever had, but worth it.

    55555 by Corinne


  • Erika N.Best cheese curds in town!

    55555 by Erika N.


  • Wanda G.Love the chicken sandwich

    55555 by Wanda G.


  • Alexander H.Kurt is the greatest bartender I've ever had. That guy knows his drinks. He hooked us up with the best Old Fashions on earth. Thanks Kurt!!

    55555 by Alexander H.


  • Sheila VGood place to start off the evening up town!

    55555 by Sheila V


  • LaneGreat place! Good beer selection and tasty burgers. Cheese Curds

    55555 by Lane


  • Corey JacobMy favorite dish is the beer cheese mac n cheese. Be sure to add bacon.

    55555 by Corey Jacob


  • Lisa HinchliffeWell, one obviously recommends any of the old fashioneds!

    33333 by Lisa Hinchliffe


  • Melissa D.52 beers on tap, 100 in the bottle... Sam the bartender was very friendly and helpful and gave us several fun samples!

    55555 by Melissa D.


  • Josh BrzeszkiewiczHave a No. 34 tuna sandwich for something lighter.

    55555 by Josh Brzeszkiewicz


  • John JGreat beer list very good service and food

    55555 by John J


  • Jake S.Mandatory: Cheese curds with Tiger Sauce

    55555 by Jake S.


  • Mark SFantastic, great menu!

    55555 by Mark S


  • Brett W.Try the applejack old fashioned.

    55555 by Brett W.


  • Kiley LLoved the Tuna Salad Sandwich!!

    55555 by Kiley L


  • Stephanie MExtensive beer list. Foods amazing.

    55555 by Stephanie M


  • Minh N.Spicy Burger. One of the best burgers in the nation!

    55555 by Minh N.


  • Jaclyn O.Best cheese curds in all of Wisconsin.

    55555 by Jaclyn O.


  • Matt C.Great cheese curds!

    55555 by Matt C.


  • Christopher B.Beer cheese curds burger in this order or something like this

    33333 by Christopher B.


  • Tara R.THE CHEESE CURDS!!! 😍😍 That is all.

    55555 by Tara R.


  • Sean P KelleyLove the bloody marys

    55555 by Sean P Kelley


  • Brian L.Spicy burger, spicy burger, spicy burger!

    55555 by Brian L.


  • Alex R.Cheese curds

    55555 by Alex R.


  • Brian G.Gluten free friendly!

    55555 by Brian G.


  • ZigPretty sure the cheese curd recipe is a Rob Ford original.

    55555 by Zig


  • Jonathan R.Rye bourbon old fashioned was pretty tasty!

    55555 by Jonathan R.


  • Lisa B.Best old fashion I have had on years (whiskey sour with olives)

    55555 by Lisa B.


  • James B.Try the Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet - A Wisconsin favorite! (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by James B.


  • Walt F.Best food in Wisconsin in two trips so far.... Try my beer

    55555 by Walt F.


  • James B.Excellent cheese curds!

    55555 by James B.


  • James B.They make the best Brandy Old Fashion cocktails in Madison.

    55555 by James B.


  • kris g.The beer battered cheese curds and the chicken fried steak were out of this world!

    55555 by kris g.


  • Tabitha W.Prime rib dinner was amazing! And don't forget to get a Grasshopper martini to compliment your meal it makes for a great after dinner drink!

    55555 by Tabitha W.


  • Adriana A.Cheese curds are a MUST. We split the Spicy and The Old Fashioned burger... both were out of this world !

    55555 by Adriana A.


  • Cindy D.I don't know what they do to thier cheese curds but they are one of the best things I have ever ate!! And thier BLT with fresh mozzerella is delish.

    55555 by Cindy D.


  • Kim V.Get their BLT!!! Everything was so fresh. Best BLT I've EVER had in my life!

    55555 by Kim V.


  • Amy H.Breakfast is super affordable and delicious. The local sausage is incredible!

    55555 by Amy H.


  • Wanda G.love #37 with no mustard. My favorite and is the best reason to eat at The Old Fashioned

    55555 by Wanda G.


  • Lisa F.Cheese curds are good

    55555 by Lisa F.


  • Sean B.Try the #50

    55555 by Sean B.


  • Toni S.Excellent everything!!!!

    55555 by Toni S.


  • Alice F.Try the Deep Fried Cheese Curds - These are the best. Not healthy, but good. (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Alice F.


  • Alice F.Try the House Burger - Lots going on here...fried egg, bacon, cheddar, and I added fresh jalapenos. Fork and knife burger. (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Alice F.


  • Alice F.Try the Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet - Traditional Wisconsin drink. I only drink them when in Wisconsin. (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Alice F.


  • kristen m.So good and pretty good prices. Can be a long wait tho

    55555 by kristen m.


  • Nekole F.Best cheese curds anywhere!

    55555 by Nekole F.


  • TerryThis is not kid friendly. Although there is an extensive kid menu, the atmosphere and restaurant is not conducive to kids. There isn't anything fun for them to do.

    55555 by Terry


  • Teresita C.Got turned away, at age 38 because I forgot ID! Don't forget yours!

    22222 by Teresita C.


  • KK A.Get the cheese curds and TWO dips: paprika and ranch.

    55555 by KK A.


  • Matt S.Wow, they weren't kidding, best cheese curds ever, hands down. And the bloody is fantastic too.

    55555 by Matt S.


  • Rich W.If you're not a local, get a flight of Wisconsin beers. It's the best way to experience their fine brews. And believe the hype on the cheese curds too....wow!

    55555 by Rich W.


  • Erin H.The Tiger sauce make the amazing cheese curds even better!

    55555 by Erin H.


  • Jodie B.I love the number 35!!!

    55555 by Jodie B.


  • Jill M.Cheese curds are the best.

    55555 by Jill M.


  • Samantha A.Cheese. Curds.

    55555 by Samantha A.


  • Darren P.Ask for the Spicy Wisconsin Bloody Mary! It's a meal in a glass that will keep your metabolism running!

    55555 by Darren P.


  • AmberGreat beer list, GREAT! But they served me pink chicken then didn't comp it.

    33333 by Amber


  • Jake S.This isn't just a Wisconsin beer bar. Be sure to check out the imported beer they have too!

    55555 by Jake S.


  • Chris V.Their Thursday special ribs come on a bed of pulled pork. That's right - meat on a bed of meat.

    55555 by Chris V.


  • Louis D.Sit at the bar for no wait. (There is another bar in the back with more stools. )

    33333 by Louis D.


  • ClarasssaurusEGG BURGERRRRRRR!!!!

    55555 by Clarasssaurus


  • Vinod S.I got no beef with this place. Friendly bartenders!

    55555 by Vinod S.


  • EaterMadison food writer Kyle Nabilcy: "Its thick pub-style burgers, has provided a gateway for a younger generation's appreciation of Wisconsin supper club culture. Mondays are two-for-one burger nights."

    55555 by Eater


  • That's right! I'mDon't be surprised! It will probably be 40-60 minute wait. This place is popular.

    33333 by That's right! I'm


  • Sean G.Be sure to order the "Beer Bomb" for a unique taste of WI.

    55555 by Sean G.


  • Traci A.The cheese curds are the best!

    55555 by Traci A.


  • Cari JThis place is awesome!

    55555 by Cari J


  • Paul CThe OF should be on every Madison " must do" list

    55555 by Paul C


  • David W.Great place, good food and 40 beers on tap. Cheese. Curds are a must

    55555 by David W.


  • Anne AMac n cheese is VERY salty and not so cheesy

    33333 by Anne A


  • Tony V.If you didn't order the cheese curds, you missed out. Wonderful.

    33333 by Tony V.


  • Jen Y.Cheese curds and the #29 Spicy Burger. It's like heaven, times bacon.

    55555 by Jen Y.


  • Tenley M.Try a band old fashion sweet with bittercube's cherry bark vanilla! Amazing!

    55555 by Tenley M.


  • Courtney D.Cheese curds and beer yum

    55555 by Courtney D.


  • Matthew R.Arguably the best cheese curds in Madison. However, if you try to come here on a friday or saturday night you'll be waiting ~ 1 hour for a table.

    55555 by Matthew R.


  • CherryDelish soup and salad fresh from the Farmers Market from the square with a great amount of dressing.

    55555 by Cherry


  • Justine B.The house burger is amazing. The cheese curds are amazing. The beer is amazing. See a trend?

    55555 by Justine B.


  • Cindy U.Love the burger and goosh of the egg!!

    55555 by Cindy U.


  • Jeff B.Make sure your whole party is present. Hosts are ruthlessly strict about the waiting list, and you won't be in line for a table 'till everyone has presented themselves at the hostess stand.

    33333 by Jeff B.


  • NicoleHave Cameron as your bartender. Sexy mother fucker.

    55555 by Nicole


  • Brad G.Lunch is such a cluster here... Order at the bar? Also, computer is down and orders that are already paid for are taking more than 90 minutes. No compensation? That is nuts!

    22222 by Brad G.


  • WyattThis place is freaking amazing! If you're at the bar ask for Kurt, great guy, knows his stuff and will have a beer taster line going for you in no time.

    55555 by Wyatt


  • Dustin L.Wait awhile.

    55555 by Dustin L.


  • Lea R.Don't use the foursquare special..they don't honor it

    11111 by Lea R.


  • AndrewThe cheese curds are awesome.

    55555 by Andrew


  • khriscatcheese curds with ranch

    55555 by khriscat


  • Chris R.Picked up a stomach virus, took me two weeks to recover. Not ready to go back.

    11111 by Chris R.


  • laura h.Do not even think about getting out of here without eating the cheese curds!!

    33333 by laura h.


  • Mitsuko M.Decent burger, okay mac 'n cheese, addicting haystack onion strings. Overall the food was good, however when it came to service this place was seriously lacking.

    33333 by Mitsuko M.


  • Kristina P.Try the Pearl St Pilsner.

    55555 by Kristina P.


  • Jim A.Try the Beer Battered Cheese Curds - Truly astounding! Possibly the best cheese curds I've ever eaten. But...I'll keep testing that theory. (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Beer Flight - The Beer Flight includes 4x 3 oz Snits for a mere $4. I chose 35. Shine On, 37. Lupulin Maximus, 38. 3 ft. Deep Stout & 49. Amber (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Wurst Platter (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Beer Flight - 35, 37, 38 & 49 (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Beef Jerky (via @Foodspotting)

    33333 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Spicy Pickled Egg (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Jim A.Try the Beer Battered Cheese Curds (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Jim A.


  • Alice F.Try the Wurst Platter - Knockwurst, weisswurst and bratwurst (via @Foodspotting)

    55555 by Alice F.


  • Brett R.$1.50 tacos and $6.50 Patron silver margaritas on Tuesdays!!

    55555 by Brett R.


  • Donna R.I didn't get to ready here because I was too hungry to wait 1.5 hours at 7:30pm, but it smelled incredible in here. Bummed.

    22222 by Donna R.


  • Nick H.Two words: turkey gizzerds.

    55555 by Nick H.


  • Pete N.Eggs Benedict

    55555 by Pete N.


  • Alex D.The cheese curds are the best I've had in Madison and the Spicy Burger was great!

    55555 by Alex D.


  • Rishi K.All new beers are on tap! Come check 'em out. Matt's the best bartender

    55555 by Rishi K.


  • 77 SquareThe Old Fashioned is one of the oldest cocktails in existence. Have one now! For other entertainment fun in the palm of your hand download the new 77 Square app. Free for iPhones!

    55555 by 77 Square


  • Bill C.Get the prime rib special. Super Yum!

    55555 by Bill C.


  • Robin R.Brunch awesome..

    55555 by Robin R.


  • Sara M.The House burger is outstanding!

    55555 by Sara M.


  • Justina D.Boyfriend said after having the #30, "I feel bad for any other burger I have for the rest of my life."

    33333 by Justina D.


  • Nicole R.There are FIFTY Wisconsin beers on tap here.

    55555 by Nicole R.


  • Meredith B.Tuna salad sandwich is delish, but get it w/o the red peppers.

    55555 by Meredith B.


  • Shayla M.The #20 salad with cherries is my favorite! The cheese curds are some of the best curds I've had in Wisco too!

    55555 by Shayla M.


  • Genesis AThe best cheese curds in Madison!!!

    55555 by Genesis A


  • Jel T.the brandy slush here is soo good!!!!

    55555 by Jel T.


  • Joey RDon't be "that guy" and order a miller or bud light.

    55555 by Joey R


  • Greg B.Best burgers in the country.

    55555 by Greg B.


  • Joe H.Sit at the bar for immediate service! Petes ur man behind the bar

    33333 by Joe H.


  • Justin H.They have the best roast beef in the city.

    55555 by Justin H.


  • Emily Z.Best cheese curds in the entire world

    55555 by Emily Z.


  • Michael BHad the tastiest dinner ever: cheese curds (the best ever), beer cheese soup, and the House Burger (wowface!), all topped off with an excellent New Glarus Moon Man Pale Ale. Best dinner out ever.

    55555 by Michael B


  • CollegeCandyBest cheese curds in the US. Their food is extraordinary. They have an amazing selection of beers and feature vodkas infused with fruit.

    55555 by CollegeCandy


  • Men's Health MagIt’s simple here. No. 8 if you want to split bratwurst with buddies, and No. 38 if you want one to yourself. Do yourself a favor, snag a side of mac and cheese. To drink? Easy, the Old Fashioned.

    55555 by Men's Health Mag


  • 3 Eyed S.Lakefront pumpkin lager is freaking delicious, along with they're artery clogging curds

    55555 by 3 Eyed S.


  • Jake V.GREAT place! Love it. Great food. Great drinks. Always poppin at night

    55555 by Jake V.


  • Blake R.Get your Wisconsin on. They have an amazing (and huge) tap list of Wisconsin beers, and the food feature all the classic Wisconsin fare. The lazy susans are outstanding.

    55555 by Blake R.


  • Meredith N.GREAT breakfast and fast service.

    55555 by Meredith N.


  • Brian PShitty service. Left us in a sun blazed table without explanation or apology.

    11111 by Brian P


  • Arshia MPeach Crisp-not so crispy.

    55555 by Arshia M


  • Joseph T.Way over crowded on Friday nights. Was told an hr to hr and 15 minutes. Waited 2 hours for table. Food was alright but not worth the 2 hr wait.

    22222 by Joseph T.


  • Michael DThe burgers and cheese curds are amazing!!!

    55555 by Michael D


  • rosaAmazing brunch too!!! Always a wait, but late night is much less crowded.

    55555 by rosa


  • UrbanLuxTangerine IPA -Potosi Brewery (if you like Beer, you will like this)

    55555 by UrbanLux


  • Faustina B.Wednesday karaoke

    55555 by Faustina B.


  • Pete M.Love the apple jack Old Fashioned. Plus, any place that has Potosi on tap is a winner with me.

    55555 by Pete M.


  • Pete M.Love the Applejack Old Fashioned. Any place that has Potosi on tap and a library of small town Wisconsin brews is a fave.

    55555 by Pete M.


  • Bobbi S.Ask for the tiger sauce. And if you're around for brunch, get a bloody mary but be prepared if you get one with a hot pickled egg, you better have high pain tolerance (I don't!)

    55555 by Bobbi S.


  • Crystal P.Don't leave without ordering a Korbel Brandy Old Fashioned!

    55555 by Crystal P.


  • Ryan W.Get a gin old fashioned... Bombay sapphire with sweet or press. Sounds a little funny but u won't be disappointed

    55555 by Ryan W.


  • Teresa P.No A/C! And double whatever time they tell you for the wait!

    22222 by Teresa P.


  • Alicia B.Best cheese curds! So good with the paprika sauce! The brat is served cut in half and sandwich style, FYI. :)

    55555 by Alicia B.


  • Renae L.Upstairs is a good choice if you intend on holding a conversation. Upstairs stops service at nine, though. Mac and cheese- okay at best- I've had much better at other places. You can get a side of it

    55555 by Renae L.


  • Renae L.Chicken sandwich was good. Typical American cousin. Cheese curds were great. Extra treat was their crisp. Strawberry rhubarb crisp a la mode was delish.

    55555 by Renae L.


  • Charles T.Try the Apple Pie - Unique

    55555 by Charles T.


  • Stephen T.The upstairs is quieter and has a great view of the Capital. The PF was recommended by my new son!

    55555 by Stephen T.


  • Cameron M.Best. Cheese. Curds. Ever!

    55555 by Cameron M.


  • Joe PDecent food, SLOW service

    33333 by Joe P


  • Brigid H.The $2 beer of the month is a great excuse to try a new and usually unique beer.

    55555 by Brigid H.


  • Lindsey RBest sunday brunch in town

    55555 by Lindsey R


  • Jess D.can't go wrong with anything.

    55555 by Jess D.


  • Arthur W.Excellent food!! Try the Wisconsin cheese soup. It's to die for!

    55555 by Arthur W.


  • Jason H.The beer and cheese curds were excellent. What else would one expect from The Old Fashioned!

    55555 by Jason H.


  • Sajia HThe grilled cheese is fantastic!

    55555 by Sajia H


  • AlisonThe beer flight is super-cheap and fun!

    55555 by Alison


  • Training With BjornGet the Norwegian Salmon salad! Yum!

    55555 by Training With Bjorn


  • JS F.You MUST get the cheese curds. Even if you don't think you'll like them. I think they put crack in them.

    55555 by JS F.


  • Andrew M.BFBL Partner since Spring 2007

    55555 by Andrew M.


  • Chris V.This place was great. Perfect place to go on the way back to Chicago from skiing.

    55555 by Chris V.


  • Terrenceget a #30. its that simple

    33333 by Terrence


  • Heavy TableThe state’s best cheesemakers contribute to the peerless cheese plates.

    55555 by Heavy Table


  • Jason S.Get the Cheese Curds w/ the Tiger Blue.

    55555 by Jason S.


  • Paul RExcellent food and a great selection of Wisconsin beer.

    55555 by Paul R


  • Ian B.Dont be shy... The old fashioned burger is the way to go!

    55555 by Ian B.


  • Geo S.Plus - giant cookies for a buck!

    55555 by Geo S.


  • Megan CCheese curds with tiger and ranch sauce. You won't be disappointed.

    55555 by Megan C


  • Lyndsey T.Get an "old fashioned" drink and burger.

    55555 by Lyndsey T.


Map of The Old Fashioned

Restaurants similar to The Old Fashioned

Nearby Restaurants

Events in Madison