> >


Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar



4 South Elmwood Avenue
Montauk, NY 11954

View more Montauk restaurants

(631) 668-4200

Hours

  • Sunday: 5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
  • Monday: 5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: 5:00 pm - 11:00 pm
  • Saturday: 5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Cuisine: Bars, Seafood Restaurants


4.8 of 5.0 from 72 reviews

menu

Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free


Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY
  • Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar in Montauk, NY

Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar Reviews

Add your review for Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar.

  • Rachel MTuna tartare, ice cream sandwich, Brussels sprouts

    55555 by Rachel M


  • Britta TThe crispy chicken was incredible!

    55555 by Britta T


  • ArdvaarkOrder the truffle fries with your meal instead of as an appetizer. They're huge, and delicious, but if you eat them all you won't have room for dinner.

    55555 by Ardvaark


  • ArdvaarkThe Octopus Tacos are killer. They come in two or four, and are a great plate to share.

    55555 by Ardvaark


  • D VGreat dessert options. Solid dinner menu, but unfortunately the service is quite bad and takes away from the experience.

    33333 by D V


  • Lisa VoldeckThe service is fast and friendly but the menu is a little pretentious. The food is decent, but could be simpler and better.

    55555 by Lisa Voldeck


  • Pamela WYellow fin tuna and rose amazing

    55555 by Pamela W


  • jana f.Get the kale salad and cauliflower. Sweet little spot.

    55555 by jana f.


  • Wayne BennettEverything good but they take creativity to foods that should be kept simple. Montauk mojitos good. Don't go nuts on the octopus tacos. $30 for two pieces of local fluke?

    33333 by Wayne Bennett


  • Ashley B.Tremendous food. Fettuccine and octopus tacos were amazing. Service was a little shaky.

    55555 by Ashley B.


  • PureWowGet a drink from the bar’s pickle martini station: Choose one of ten gins or vodkas and then pick your “pickle”--options include asparagus, green beans, ramps, Fresno peppers, cherries and more.

    55555 by PureWow


  • Damian BayonaHave to try the BLT. The lobster is also delicious and very well priced.

    55555 by Damian Bayona


  • James UnderbergLoved the dinner here ! Oysters and BLT Tuna Chalupa followed by the Chili dusted Fresh local scallops - run here ! Don't walk !!!

    55555 by James Underberg


  • Michael JacobsonThey added 'smoked lobster' to the menu. It is AMAZING, and very reasonable price for lobster. A must try.

    55555 by Michael Jacobson


  • Oskar V.They cancel your reservations :/ watch out!

    11111 by Oskar V.


  • Benjamin P.I think this place is closed

    33333 by Benjamin P.


  • MaritzaEverything is great. Drinks and oysters and great wines.

    55555 by Maritza


  • Tracy QuiFood is fabulous great clam appetizer and plainchant fluke cooked to perfection.

    55555 by Tracy Qui


  • Norah L.The last 2 times I've been here, I've been disappointed with food and service. May be end of an era.

    55555 by Norah L.


  • Kimberly ASoft shell crab is a must !

    55555 by Kimberly A


  • Jocelyn WPickled martini

    55555 by Jocelyn W


  • Katie R.Menu looks great, not the best execution though. All food is good but not great

    55555 by Katie R.


  • Flo P.Highly recommend the clam bake + scallops tartare!

    55555 by Flo P.


  • melanie a.Octopus Tacos for Mayor of Montauk. And Coconut Baked Alaskaaaaah. The most charming dining room.

    55555 by melanie a.


  • Jennifer M.Belly clams are a must-try. Have with a pint of Summer Shandy and roasted kale from local East Hampton farm.

    55555 by Jennifer M.


  • Ashley C.My favorite restaurant in Montauk. They discontinued the peppers appetizer but still have their signature dishes like the spicy tuna BLT chalupa. The Cavatelli and the stiped bass are off the hook.

    55555 by Ashley C.


  • Jason R.Amazing raw bar. Oysters and clams

    55555 by Jason R.


  • Ryan M.Lobster Buns! Do it!!

    55555 by Ryan M.


  • Kelvin P.Excelent service and food

    55555 by Kelvin P.


  • Jess S.Best in mtk. Oysters, octopus tacos, grilled romaine salad (amaze) and grilled prawns. You're welcome.

    55555 by Jess S.


  • MaritzaMake reservations, bar is too small for last minute drop ins :-/

    55555 by Maritza


  • Maridi N.This is a great restaurant for a low carb diet!!!

    55555 by Maridi N.


  • Maridi N.The Berry Mojito, Baby Octopus Tacos, Porgy a la Plancha, and Salted Caramel Ice Cream Bar are all winners!

    55555 by Maridi N.


  • Erin O.The seared tuna was amazing!

    55555 by Erin O.


  • omar y.This fisherman's dive bar is open till 4am

    55555 by omar y.


  • omar y.Octopus tacos are legit!

    55555 by omar y.


  • Three JaneNot great for big parties, so grab two stools at the bar, and order the whole menu. Seriously. Kale salad, octopus tacos, oysters... A definite Montauk favorite.

    55555 by Three Jane


  • EdwinThe octopus tacos are awesome

    55555 by Edwin


  • Evan H.Best deal in montauk happy hr with dollar blueprints and 3 dollar blue point drafts

    55555 by Evan H.


  • Jamie (.Great option for walk-ins, plenty of room inside and out to wait with drinks. Warning: half portions are not avail in season.

    55555 by Jamie (.


  • David M.$1 oysters and $3 blue point drafts during happy hour!

    55555 by David M.


  • Stephanie H.Great! Try the Tilefish a La Plancha or the Spicy Tuna BLT! There should be a few more selections on the menu though...

    55555 by Stephanie H.


  • Sally R.Octopus tacos!

    55555 by Sally R.


  • Maxine B.Get a table by the window and try to come before / during sunset. Watercress salad is light and delicious, and the salmon has a nice middle eastern influence.

    55555 by Maxine B.


  • Cynthia B.The ice cream sandwich with salted caramel ice cream is incredible. Ask for extra ice cream.

    55555 by Cynthia B.


  • Ashley G.Rock shrimp linguine, tuna chipotle tacos and of course the lobster rolls are legen...dary!

    55555 by Ashley G.


  • Monsta M.Aaaaawesome food, great service and perfect atmoshere and vibe. Has a steak that was so big, it had a license plate on it! lmaoooo! Cant wait to come back!

    55555 by Monsta M.


  • marc j.Pizza to go.

    55555 by marc j.


  • Kate G.Get Chef Mitgang's Shrimp and Grits Fra Diavalo. It's rich, spicy and a genius twist on the Southern classic.

    55555 by Kate G.


  • Katie P.Give yourself at least a half hour to get anything you order including beer and appetizers. Ridiculous.

    33333 by Katie P.


  • Natalie S.Sit at the bar, order the oysters with spinach and cheese and the pizza with sausage, peppers, gorgonzola- you'll be stuffed and so happy.

    55555 by Natalie S.


  • Eugenie H.Not stroller friendly and they won't seat you till your whole party arrives. Told us to take sleeping tot out of stroller and let him sleep on wooden bench. It may be MTK but they think they are NYC.

    33333 by Eugenie H.


  • Mitchell S.The Pepper Gimlet is awesome! Just a hint of Pepper and the end of each sip, not in a very spicy way. A must have!!!!

    55555 by Mitchell S.


  • Cecilia S.Must get: octopus tacos! And all the seafood dishes are great.

    55555 by Cecilia S.


  • Social DivaThe Lobster Roll is Ridic! Yum.

    55555 by Social Diva


  • Mark D.Try the salt and vinegar fried peppers.

    55555 by Mark D.


  • Nate K.U can always find me here either in the kitchen or on the floor. I'm friendly

    55555 by Nate K.


  • Nile N.Ask for Denver! He was great, definitely added to the meal.

    55555 by Nile N.


  • DensUm, they have take-away growlers here for $13 (+ $5 growler fee)

    55555 by Dens


  • Shawn H.The burger is a secret don't tell anyone!

    55555 by Shawn H.


  • Fred W.The Lamb Ribs the Octopus Tacos and the tuna BLT are all great

    55555 by Fred W.


  • Ellie R.Happy hour outside on Sunday's, good brews. $3 beers.

    55555 by Ellie R.


  • Local KnitCheck out the official Harvest tee at localknit.com! (and don't forget to try the whole roasted fish special next time you check in...)

    55555 by Local Knit


  • Tom L.Beautiful view and leftovers for days.

    55555 by Tom L.


  • The Corcoran GroupSpectacular waterfront dining with Mediterranean Cuisine; on premises catering. The portions are huge so order smart!

    55555 by The Corcoran Group


  • Victor M.Wow. Try the spicy tuna BLT chalupa.

    55555 by Victor M.


  • Landy L.Great little chic spot for dinner and drinks

    55555 by Landy L.


  • EdwinGreat corn soup and raw bar. The fish of the day 'a la plancha' with fennel, apple, and crab sauce is usually excellent.

    55555 by Edwin


  • M F.Hippest place in Montauk - Spicy Tuna BLT?

    55555 by M F.


  • ThrillistSE's got a rotating selection of oysters (Eagle Creek, Blue Point, Point Julia, Flowers…), Little Necks & Cherrystones, shrimp/lobster cocktails, and Alaskan king and Jonah crabs.

    55555 by Thrillist


  • Amanda L.Delicious food with huge portions! Definitely plan to share.

    55555 by Amanda L.


  • Tonia R.Beautiful garden + a dock where you can feed the fish and ducks.

    55555 by Tonia R.


Map of Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar

Restaurants similar to Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar

Nearby Restaurants