Brewster's Italian Cafe

Brewster's Italian Cafe Reviews

Add your review for Brewster's Italian Cafe.

• Super friendly staff. The roasted red pepper florentine soup is delicious! They have indoor and outdoor seating, including a great sun room inside and flame heaters outside when it's cool.

  by Gregory H.

  
  

• Nice intimate cafe in New Buffalo.

  by David W.

  
  

• "Dinner for 2" special: Amazeballs!!! 2-topping pizza PLUS any dinner entree with 2 soups or salads PLUS cookies and coffee for dessert = $35. WOW!

  by Devon Nichols

  
  

• Sea Bass was absolutely incredible!

  by Lisa B.

  
  

• Queens caprese salad.. Nuff said, get it

  by Scott S.

  
  

• Beware: the Roma tortellini pasta is HEAVY on garlic. Bring mints, Listerine, vampires, etc.

  by Sam B.

  
  

• It's Chicagoan gridlock in the summer, but we'll worth the hassle. In the winter, cozy up with your honey, and get the Dinner for Two.

  by Rachel P.

  
  

• Enjoyed Bellini with delicious crab cakes and rustic steak salad. Amazing food and dining al fresco . Can't wait to go back .

  by Olga P.

  
  

• Good food and service. We split the Queen Margherita antipasti and two topping pizza (sausage and mushrooms). Just right for a light dinner for the two of us. Pizza had great crust and good flavors.

  by Janis E.

  
  

• Amazing food and awesome service. I wouldn't hesitate to come back any time.

  by Travis S.

  
  

• Love their olive oil based pizza and tri-cheese tortilinni

  by Codi L.

  
  

• Dinner for two was an overwhelmingly great deal. Plus, the food was great! The apple cookie was to die for

  by Nicolette H.

  
  

• Dinner for 2 is the way to go! You won't go hone hungry. Plus the pizza is like REAL Italian pizza!

  by Shannon M.

  
  

• Dinner for 2 is a great deal and so is the food. Patio in good weather just adds to the enjoyment.

  by Louis P.

  
  

• The Chicken Florintine Soup is incredible.

  by John K.

  
  

• Try the Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie (via @Foodspotting)

  by Julie F.

  
  

• Try the Crab Cakes With Red Pepper Remoulade (via @Foodspotting)

  by Julie F.

  
  

• Excellent pizzas!

  by Tim R.

  
  

• Great tiramisu. And the house dressing is terrific

  by Kelly C.

  
  

• Great food, great service! Ashley rocks! And don't miss dessert and coffee... some of the best coffee around!

  by Corinne

  
  

• White chocolate macadamian cookies--perfect finish! Also great tiramisu

  by Kelly C.

  
  

• Dara is great server. Get spinach artichoke dip. One of the best Italian meals I've had.

  by Maribeth H.

  
  

• Call ahead to be seated faster!

  by Pamela V.

  
  

• Brewster's has one of the best outdoor dining spaces that I have seen.

  by Dennis K.

  
  

• Can't wait to go!!

  by Mike M.

  
  

• Great spot! Menu changes daily. Staff is excellent - friendly - and accomodating.

  by Nicole Y.

  
  

• Dinner for two is amazing!!!

  by Michelle M.