Looking for restaurants open for Easter?

> >

Oddfellows Ice Cream

62 Spring Street
New York, NY 10012

View more New York restaurants

(347) 599-0556


  • Sunday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Monday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Tuesday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Wednesday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Thursday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Friday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Saturday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Find Oddfellows Ice Cream on Twitter Facebook

Cuisine: Ice Cream

4.8 of 5.0 from 198 reviews

Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free

Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY
  • Oddfellows Ice Cream in New York, NY

Oddfellows Ice Cream Reviews

Add your review for Oddfellows Ice Cream.

  • Emiliano ViscarraI've tried the chocolate and tangerine soft and was super nice.

    55555 by Emiliano Viscarra

  • Nicole ANice light and fun atmosphere. The waffle cones are great, but eat them fast because they leak!

    55555 by Nicole A

  • Tiffany Jstacked ice cream cone

    55555 by Tiffany J

  • Diana S.Thai tea ice cream and I can't recall the other one

    55555 by Diana S.

  • Kelly VIncredible ice cream ❤️ well worth the extra blocks! 😍😍

    55555 by Kelly V

  • Inna SCookies and cream ice cream in a cone!

    55555 by Inna S

  • Valentin G.Cookies and cream in a home made waffle cone.

    55555 by Valentin G.

  • Konstantin PVery tasty ice cream, quite expensive as well!

    55555 by Konstantin P

  • Sergey S.Very sugary and really sweet. A bit too much for my taste.

    55555 by Sergey S.

  • Trish R.Chorizo Ice Cream

    55555 by Trish R.

  • Claire DI love ice cream. I didn't love this ice cream -- poor taste/quality, poor flavor selection, stingy on hot fudge. Maybe I'll try again someday, but not anytime soon.

    33333 by Claire D

  • Guest of a GuestThis scoop shop is defying the ice cream norms with its weird and wacky flavors. The Olive Oil flavor ice cream has a unique taste and texture, and pairs well with other flavors and citrus-y sorbets.

    55555 by Guest of a Guest

  • Jean T.The lemon rosemary olive oil was a little too heavy with the olive oil. Everything else was delicious. Try the spicy pineapple (not overly spicy, just had a small kick to it), and blueberry ginger

    55555 by Jean T.

  • Josh JOlive oil ice cream is alive and well living in Bk. I'd like to put one of there shakes in my belly👌👍❤️

    55555 by Josh J

  • Justin O.Kid friendly and dog friendly. They have inventive flavors of ice cream. The tiramisu ice cream has a rich coffee flavor.

    55555 by Justin O.

  • PureWowBrioche bun + tiramisu ice cream + salted caramel drizzle + coffee crispies = dessert goals. Get the tiramisu oddpocket now.

    55555 by PureWow

  • Elizabeth PInteresting flavours of ice cream!

    55555 by Elizabeth P

  • Petros EGreat selection of flavours! Try the sundae!

    55555 by Petros E

  • Ben TNice little place - milkshakes are delicious.

    55555 by Ben T

  • Matthew BGo for the Thai tea in a waffle cone!

    55555 by Matthew B

  • Brian D.Thai iced tea and banana puddin' are both incredible, but NOT mixed in same cup

    55555 by Brian D.

  • Peter R.Try a flavour of ice cream!

    55555 by Peter R.

  • Kaya KCool flavored, great value.

    55555 by Kaya K

  • Hrag VartanianDon't bring your calorie counter here since you're going to enjoy creamy deliciousness and it's really good.

    55555 by Hrag Vartanian

  • Kira R.It's amazing place but many times the lines are unbearable

    55555 by Kira R.

  • BuzzFeedGet the brioche bun ice cream sandwiches. They have a really unique selection of flavors, and it’s all very well made.

    55555 by BuzzFeed

  • Benjamin CEverything is amazing and flavors are always changing. Be sure to taste and pick your favorite!

    55555 by Benjamin C

  • Tabitha J.Miso cherry... Just sample tons even if you think it's weird.

    55555 by Tabitha J.

  • Karan TamhaneMake your own Carrot cake cream cheese icecream + Cream soda float. DO IT!

    55555 by Karan Tamhane

  • PureWowThe milkshakes at OddFellows are an amazing treat on their own. But for your birthday, you can rent out the entire store for two hours, bring your own alcohol and concoct boozy ice cream creations.

    55555 by PureWow

  • Ryan M.Unlimited samples. Really. Don't hesitate to try everything.

    55555 by Ryan M.

  • Maribel C.Tried the chocolate chunk, olive oil strawberry, carrot creamcheese, maitake peanut, miso cherry...Me sooo happy

    55555 by Maribel C.

  • Candice RiveraBurnt caramel and burnt marshmellow were my faves! The chocolate was great too tho

    55555 by Candice Rivera

  • David G.The cold brew coffee shake is unreal

    55555 by David G.

  • Mikahla VicinoThe carrot cake ice cream is out of this world.

    55555 by Mikahla Vicino

  • Veronica CThey make their own cones

    55555 by Veronica C

  • Gail BIt's hard to say what's good cause they change there menu every day but I can say is that the ice cream is delicious and that they make there own cones my kid loves this place

    55555 by Gail B

  • Ashley MillerFlavors change all the time. The passion fruit saffron is the best one!

    55555 by Ashley Miller

  • Cameron SBest ice cream ever? Get half Coconut Kaffir and half Lemon Meringue.

    55555 by Cameron S

  • Garrison AShare one of the sundaes with the weirdest combinations of ice cream flavors you can handle.

    55555 by Garrison A

  • AllisonThat waffle cone tho... Best ever.🐒🍦🍿

    55555 by Allison

  • Kelly BWaffle cones made in-house

    55555 by Kelly B

  • Andrew JMiss cherry was great

    55555 by Andrew J

  • Paul PA tourist hotspot. But don't let this put you off, there are homemade flavours on rotation daily and you can even watch the masters at work through the huge interior window.

    55555 by Paul P

  • Martin OngBlack chocolate stout. Tastes exactly like beer!

    55555 by Martin Ong

  • Sabrina MGet their amazing ice cream on the waffle cone! So good.

    55555 by Sabrina M

  • Ashley M.Unique flavors. Get the Tahitian vanilla if they have it!

    55555 by Ashley M.

  • Gi 7Odd flavors are the best!

    55555 by Gi 7

  • GothamistIn honor of the green holiday, Odd Fellows is having a Whiskey Ice Cream special until the end of April that will mix your favorite things; holidays, ice cream, and booze. And yes, you can get drunk.

    55555 by Gothamist

  • Su BThe thai iced tea is delicious and tastes exactly like a Thai iced tea! Sprinkles is a nice staple with the sweet cream base. And the waffle cone - so good!!

    55555 by Su B

  • Sam C.Pecan pie ice cream FTW

    55555 by Sam C.

  • Tom W.The ice cream is what's good here. If you are lactose intolerant they have Lactaid tablets for you.

    55555 by Tom W.

  • Rudy V.Lots of flavors and they rotate often. The clowns are kinda creepy

    55555 by Rudy V.

  • Martin OngBe adventurous and try all the different flavors of ice cream they have!

    55555 by Martin Ong

  • Basak H.This place is full of surprises. Who knew chorizo or beets would be so flavorful!? One of my many personal favorites is brown butter sage.

    55555 by Basak H.

  • Sean NickleyTry the Thai iced tea ice cream

    55555 by Sean Nickley

  • Elynn L.Definitely recommend the brown butter sage ice cream and the pear sorbet! Really amazing ice cream and inventive flavors.

    55555 by Elynn L.

  • C RCreative flavors, but I would expect more flavorful and smoother ice cream from a WD-50 alum. Smores and coconut are recommended... need to try more creative flavors, to find one I like...

    55555 by C R

  • John DuncanIce cream was a little too adventurous

    55555 by John Duncan

  • Shivani JCoffee milkshake! Made with cold brew

    55555 by Shivani J

  • Jennifer S.the thai tea flavor is the best.

    55555 by Jennifer S.

  • Elysia M.Go big or go home- try a flavor that scares you

    55555 by Elysia M.

  • Lindsay KirkMiso cherry when they have it- gets me every time

    55555 by Lindsay Kirk

  • Sean S.Oddball, but delicious flavors. Make sure to try a sample so you know what you are getting into.

    55555 by Sean S.

  • Ma VChocolate pudding

    55555 by Ma V

  • Alia Ormut-Fleishmana flavor called sprinkle that contains sprinkles is basically all I need to live.

    33333 by Alia Ormut-Fleishman

  • Stephanie M.A little expensive but totally worth it. Definitely agree the buttermilk honey blueberry is amazeballs

    55555 by Stephanie M.

  • Ben G.Delicious unique ice cream. Get the PB&J or Thai tea

    55555 by Ben G.

  • Saif D.Some interesting flavours to complement a great interior

    55555 by Saif D.

  • Qiana SThe unique ice cream flavors

    55555 by Qiana S

  • Peter L.Excellent ice cream very inventive flavors. Cute shop.

    55555 by Peter L.

  • Alaaddin AkkayaBest icecream in the world

    55555 by Alaaddin Akkaya

  • Abby O.They make your waffle cone on the spot so it's fresh and they have a great selection of ice creams

    55555 by Abby O.

  • Abe AnwarGreat variety! Check out the Banana Pudding flavor.

    55555 by Abe Anwar

  • Tara D.Thai tea ice cream on a hot summer day will zen you like no other.

    55555 by Tara D.

  • ImSo_BrooklynGood for dates.. The view is nice. Reminds me of an old 50's shop!

    55555 by ImSo_Brooklyn

  • Molly MToo much dried apricot in the passion fruit, but the toasted coconut in a root beer float was delicious.

    55555 by Molly M

  • Danny JThis place has the best music.

    55555 by Danny J

  • when we roam KFlavors are out of this world! Yum yum!

    55555 by when we roam K

  • Mai N.They have lactaid pills for 50 cents for us lactose intolerant folks.

    33333 by Mai N.

  • Shirlene W.Try the cherry miso ice cream. Is delicious

    55555 by Shirlene W.

  • Meg Farmerworth the wait. seriously, go for the PBJ.

    33333 by Meg Farmer

  • Livia BSorveteria linda linda! Provei o sorvete de maracujá com pistache e açafrão: incrível! Ah, eles fazem a casquinha do sorvete na hora ❤️

    33333 by Livia B

  • Elio JWeird but good, I recommend the olive oil taste.

    55555 by Elio J

  • Lais TCelery peanut butter raisins ice cream 💚

    55555 by Lais T

  • Olivia EGreat ice cream with crazy flavored

    55555 by Olivia E

  • William H.Thai ice cream and coffee chunk!

    55555 by William H.

  • Jean B.Look for the current wifi password on the bottom of the Featured Specials board on your right. Also, there are outlets along the wall beneath the windows.

    33333 by Jean B.

  • Sunny H.PB&J is amazing but there are no bad choices here.

    55555 by Sunny H.

  • Leah L.Cornbread😍

    55555 by Leah L.

  • Filter Scan / SeanAbsolutely the best ice cream. Get the pecan pie ice cream with a house made cone. It's worth the calories and money.

    55555 by Filter Scan / Sean

  • Leigh Ann Q.I am not one for weird tasting flavors, I'm pretty boring...and since that's all they offer, I just close my eyes and pick! I've never been disappointed! Everything is delicious.

    55555 by Leigh Ann Q.

  • EdGrapefruit jalapeño sorbet is unusual and delicious.

    55555 by Ed

  • nikki austinI had the sprinkles in a waffle cone! So good. The waffle cones have a lot of cinnamon in them!

    55555 by nikki austin

  • Tom JosephDelicious ice cream and unusual flavours

    55555 by Tom Joseph

  • Peter W.Get a crazy flavor and go enjoy it on the waterfront!

    55555 by Peter W.

  • Lily SOlive oil!!!!!!!

    33333 by Lily S

  • Kimberley S.Chorizo caramel swirl & maple bacon pecan ice cream flavors sound odd but they are absolutely irresistible😍

    55555 by Kimberley S.

  • Nicole FormicaBe sure to sample all flavors for that day. Menu always has something new and delicious. Never settle for anything less than your ice cream being served in their homemade waffle cones!

    55555 by Nicole Formica

  • zia osmanEVERYTHING OMG I'm a fan girl

    55555 by zia osman

  • Donna McTourist tip: Love the creaminess and full flavors of their ice cream - sprinkles (sweet cream and sprinkles) and oatmeal cookie dough are my not so odd picks...but you should try their "odd" flavors!

    55555 by Donna Mc

  • Dina RughaniThey have different flavors every week. The flavors are unique and the ice cream is creamy

    55555 by Dina Rughani

  • Julia M.Try them all, but be daring: the rotating special flavours don't do testers. The olive oil flavour, which surprisingly is in the regular rotation is my absolute fave.

    55555 by Julia M.

  • The Tastes that Make the CityThe chorizo caramel swirl is the best ice cream in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition."

    55555 by The Tastes that Make the City

  • Lori L.The typical flavors, like the Apple Crisp and Oatmeal Cookie Dough, are delicious, but they also offer some unique ones, like Caramelized Onion and Prosciutto...

    55555 by Lori L.

  • sekou shuryGreat ice cream very unique flavors as well

    55555 by sekou shury

  • Karina R.The Banana Split is highly recommended!

    55555 by Karina R.

  • Phoenix 💥💥💥Go for the honey blueberry!

    55555 by Phoenix 💥💥💥

  • Nikolas FlorosFull of amazingly good weird flavors.

    55555 by Nikolas Floros

  • ShahThis place is the best kind of insane. I had their delicious burnt marshmallow ice cream and now I want to try everything else.

    55555 by Shah

  • JuanCarlos Q.Thai iced tea icecream yummm

    55555 by JuanCarlos Q.

  • Steff HindAmazing selection of flavors ... Try the "sprinkles" for a twist on plain vanilla

    55555 by Steff Hind

  • Liang S.What the hell took me so long to come here? Some of the best ice cream. Ever. Of all time. Yes.

    55555 by Liang S.

  • Greg TackettGet a milkshake! Also, ants on a log sorbet?! So cool!

    33333 by Greg Tackett

  • Carrie SteinbergThe Cherry Soda and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Float was spectacular!

    55555 by Carrie Steinberg

  • bennsu ..Grapefruit Jalapeño Sorbet tangy and refreshing

    55555 by bennsu ..

  • Leah LabrecqueAlways try the weird flavors! So far my favorite has been the miso butterscotch with sour cherries.

    55555 by Leah Labrecque

  • Gary MThe flavor that reigns supreme will always be Miso Cherry. However, if Cornbread is available do not hesitate to get it while it lasts!

    55555 by Gary M

  • Patrick BaskinAuthentic, unique, real flavors; they have an east village location now too

    55555 by Patrick Baskin

  • Nick J.Everything was great. My gut just wishes it wasn't as close to my apartment as it is.

    55555 by Nick J.

  • Geoff R.Worth the long line. Try their crazy flavors-- delicious.

    55555 by Geoff R.

  • Justin DeanThe ice cream is great if you can get past that the branding is sterile, corny, and basic all at the same time. Miso cherry and Thai iced tea are keepers.

    55555 by Justin Dean

  • Mayu DOlive oil ice is sooooo good!

    55555 by Mayu D


    55555 by PureWow

  • Alex H.Thai Iced tea + waffle cone!

    55555 by Alex H.

  • Andrea B.Have to try the olive oil ice creamed with salted caramel on top. Ahmazing

    55555 by Andrea B.

  • Harrison W.Loved the Thai ice cream

    55555 by Harrison W.

  • Elynn L.My favorites are the olive oil and chocolate chunk! Cornbread is surprisingly good too!!

    55555 by Elynn L.

  • Karen S.Ants on a log sorbet, yes please!

    33333 by Karen S.

  • lewell are places that sell ice cream, gelato, sorbet and frozen yogurt to consumers

    55555 by lewell 

  • Angel XuIf you like variety and trying something new and of high quality, this is it you. Swear by the Thai iced cream. Mmmm

    55555 by Angel Xu

  • Kartik SathappanRaw milk ice cream

    55555 by Kartik Sathappan

  • FrancisAmazing ice cream but a long queue in hot days

    55555 by Francis

  • First We FeastOne of the most unusual and sought-after of the bunch is the shop's chorizo caramel swirl, which strikes the perfect balance between sweet and salty.

    55555 by First We Feast

  • Slawomir MYou have to try Thai. I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream ;)

    55555 by Slawomir M

  • Michichi RThai ice tea flavor is awesome

    55555 by Michichi R

  • Malik Abdur-RazzaqBurnt caramel! Tahitian Vanilla!

    33333 by Malik Abdur-Razzaq

  • Kenneth R.Thai iced tea ice cream and chocolate stout are all sorts of amazing.

    55555 by Kenneth R.

  • Anabelle P.Burnt Marshmallow & extra virgin olive oil... Yes! Taste GREAT

    55555 by Anabelle P.

  • Ellis H.Holy moly that's good ice cream. Try the Thai or burnt marshmallow

    55555 by Ellis H.

  • Leah L.Lychee!!!!

    55555 by Leah L.

  • Richie S.Don't think I've had anything better than the Thai ice tea ice cream here.

    55555 by Richie S.

  • BuzzFeed“Odd” isn’t an insult when you’re using it to describe deliciously savory-sweet combos like chorizo and caramel or miso and cherry.

    55555 by BuzzFeed

  • Lindsay D.EVOO ice cream in a freshly made waffle cone. Enjoy!

    55555 by Lindsay D.

  • Phillip TFantastic wild flavors

    55555 by Phillip T

  • VoiceStreetVillage Voice is proud to welcome OddFellows Ice Cream Co. to the 2014 Choice Eats food fest! http://bit.ly/1cRzdNV. The PB&J with Toast puts a new spin on the classic treat.

    55555 by VoiceStreet

  • Rick W.Perfect ice cream weather.

    55555 by Rick W.

  • cynthia w."Lactaid tablets available." No excuses!!!

    11111 by cynthia w.

  • The Corcoran GroupSome of the best, most original flavors of ice cream around. It's tough to name our favorite, but we are big fans of the Cornbread and the Buttermilk Honey Blueberry. We can't wait to go back!

    55555 by The Corcoran Group

  • Lolita C.Try Maple-Bacon-Peanut, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Cornbread, and/or Celery Sorbet

    55555 by Lolita C.

  • Jess CPB&J isn't a daring flavor combination like some others, but the balance of salty and sweet is classic perfection.

    55555 by Jess C

  • Laura D.ignore the fact it's a hike from the L train. the awesome flavor combinations are well worth the extra steps (& calories burned!).

    55555 by Laura D.

  • Melissa R.Crazy creative flavors, like buttermilk honey blueberry and oatmeal cookie dough.

    55555 by Melissa R.

  • Renee L.The "Thai Iced Cream" flavor has changed my life

    55555 by Renee L.

  • sharaGreat flavor combinations in this modern twist on an old timey ice cream parlor

    55555 by shara

  • Fred C.Not all of their flavors are crazy. The "sprinkles" flavor is just vanilla with sprinkles and somehow manages to be more boring than just vanilla. Also the prices are insane. Milkshake = $7.50. WTF.

    55555 by Fred C.

  • Malcolm O.Try the PB n J!

    55555 by Malcolm O.

  • Steve JReally if your waiting on a two hour line for Cronuts, you're doing it wrong. Thus support has almost no wait. Take seat art the bar and they'll get you your ice cream right there. Service; AMAZING!!!

    55555 by Steve J

  • Nina C.The lychee cilantro sorbet is delicious! Two of my favorite flavors in one. So good I took home a pint. Also, especially refreshing for a hot summer's night.

    55555 by Nina C.

  • Ben K.Possibly the best ice cream in NY right now. Crazy flavors like chorizo caramel swirl and miso cherry butterscotch. Whatever you choose make sure to get it in a waffle cone.

    55555 by Ben K.

  • laura b.They are cheap with the scoop size. It's not worth it.

    33333 by laura b.

  • Giovanni A.My gelato quest has come to an end: OddFellows Ice Cream. You won't find traditional flavours, but who cares...as long as it is creamy, tasty and delicious you can't go wrong.

    55555 by Giovanni A.

  • Catherine RMUST try the Extra Virgin Olive Oil! 👏👏💋😍

    55555 by Catherine R

  • Ciara G.Thai Tea Milkshake

    55555 by Ciara G.

  • Joe G.'Unique flavors like cornbread and chorizo caramel join conventional vanilla and chocolate at this retro ice cream parlor from Mohan and Holiday Kumar and wd~50 pastry vet Sam Mason.'

    55555 by Joe G.

  • VoiceStreetFor the ice cream connoisseurs out there who scream for adventure, OddFellows is the place to be. Order the Chorizo Caramel: a flavor so sinful but so right.

    55555 by VoiceStreet

  • Connie M.The sweet and salt combo seems to balance out. Still not sure if you'll agree to it, they allow a spoon sample to taste as many flavors they have there and you can decide which you like.

    55555 by Connie M.

  • 4rilla (.$0.50 cents extra to have your smallish ice cream scoops placed in a standard sugar cone. Get over yourself Sam. So lame. $10.00 for a pint. #williamsburgisover

    33333 by 4rilla (.

  • Jean B.This place is within running distance of my apt and walking distance of yoga... I haven't decided if that makes me happy or sad.

    33333 by Jean B.

  • arrrI expected this to be great, but the flavors and ratios of ingredients were all off. never thought I'd say 'bad ice cream,' but it was. get the basics down first ppl.

    33333 by arrr

  • Yifen J.Don't usually go for fruit flavors but the pairings are phenomenal here- buttermilk honey blueberry, banana ginger walnut. Try the crazy flavors, too, you won't regret it.

    55555 by Yifen J.

  • msfranseenChocolate chunk, purple rice, cornbread icecream flavors yum!

    55555 by msfranseen

  • Rachel W.The homemade waffle cone is a must.

    55555 by Rachel W.

  • Abby A.They have Lactaid tablets by request! HOW NICE!

    55555 by Abby A.

  • Julia S.get a waffle cone!

    55555 by Julia S.

  • Siddhartha S.Mix honey blueberry & oatmeal cookie flavors! And if you are feeling guilty after, take a walk by the Kent boardwalk at the waterfront.

    55555 by Siddhartha S.

  • Mariuxi T.The waffle cones are amazing and all their flavors are interesting....staff friendly.

    55555 by Mariuxi T.

  • Stephanie D.The buttermilk honey blueberry in a waffle cone is magical.

    55555 by Stephanie D.

  • Zayed K.Probably the best ice cream you'll have this summer. Chef Sam Mason (he of wd~50 fame) is a flavour mixing wizard. The weirder the combinations sound in your head, the better they taste in yo' mouth.

    55555 by Zayed K.

  • Gabby D.Deliciousness! Our favorites were the sprinkles, coffee, chocolate, cornbread & the maple-bacon-pecan is definitely worth a try! Plus 5cts of every ice-cream serving is donated to the Food Bank NYC!

    55555 by Gabby D.

  • Tom P.The wild combinations of flavors can distract you from what you really want...I say go with what you consider a 'safe' choice because even those are experimental at this forward thinking shop.

    55555 by Tom P.

  • Ruth H.Cornbread ice cream!!!

    55555 by Ruth H.

  • Billy CTry the oatmeal cookie dough and the buttermilk honey blueberry!

    55555 by Billy C

  • Ali P.Incredible! The owner was behind the counter and was very nice. I tried several flavors and ended up with buttermilk honey blueberry and cornbread. You will not be disappointed!!

    55555 by Ali P.

  • Zara F.Buttermilk Honey Blueberry FTW.

    55555 by Zara F.

  • Serious EatsUnique flavors like cornbread and chorizo caramel join conventional vanilla and chocolate at this retro ice cream parlor from a wd~50 pastry vet.

    55555 by Serious Eats

  • JuanCarlos Q.Cornbread Ice Cream is amazing!

    55555 by JuanCarlos Q.

  • Matt K.Still haven't tried every flavor (almost though) but so far the oatmeal cookie dough and chorizo caramel swirl are my faves.

    55555 by Matt K.

  • Cooper S.Maple Bacon Pecan, Cornbread, Chorizo Caramel Swirl, & Buttermilk Honey Blueberry are just a few of the amazing flavors you'll find. Come hungry, the staff encourages you to sample them all

    55555 by Cooper S.

  • Cooper S.Double down on the meat / ice cream pairings - Maple Bacon Pecan on top of Chorizo Caramel Swirl

    55555 by Cooper S.

  • Alissar T.Quality ice cream. Good flavors. Loved the oatmeal cookie dough and chorizo caramel

    55555 by Alissar T.

  • Sophie H.Oatmeal cookie dough for days

    55555 by Sophie H.

  • Nate B.As they're still a new shop, the staff is eager to give tastes of almost everything before you commit to a flavor. Take advantage.

    55555 by Nate B.

  • Daniel G.Chocolate Chunk + Maple Bacon = 😍

    55555 by Daniel G.

  • VoiceStreetSam Mason’s new Wonka-like Williamsburg creamery features 8-10 flavors. Be sure to check out some of the wonderfully weirder ones – and wash them down with homemade soda!

    55555 by VoiceStreet

  • jessica m. h.the housemade waffle cones are worth it - if you prefer the security of a cup like myself, just get the cone in a cup ;)

    55555 by jessica m. h.

  • Cezary P.The chorizo caramel swirl is my fave. Don't worry, the flavor is subtle.

    55555 by Cezary P.

  • Matt TCornbread + maple bacon.

    55555 by Matt T

Restaurants similar to Oddfellows Ice Cream

Nearby Restaurants

Events in New York