Looking for restaurants open on Christmas?
Peanut Butter and Co.
240 Sullivan Street
New York, NY 10012
View more New York restaurants
- Sun - Thu 11:00am - 9:00pm
- Fri - Sat 11:00am - 10:00pm
price range:$11 to $25
Is this your restaurant? Claim Your Listing
Peanut Butter and Co. Reviews
Great place to relive childhood memories, or if you're like me, experience a bit of the classical American lunch tradition I never had as a kid. Complete with brown paper bag, chips and carrot sticks.
by Florence H.
I have cravings forThe Fluffernutter shake all the way from CLEVELAND we had to come back to get it again!
by Amanda D.
Look at how they serve tea!
by Brian P.
Omg the death by peanut butter sundae is soooo phenomenal. It's orgasmic. You'll have to split it.
by Kyle W.
Lactose-free lovers, the peanut butter smoothie is made with peanut butter, honey, ice chips, and SOY milk. Mucho delicioso.
by Jessica N.
End hunger and get 10% off every time you're in the Shop! Join the Mutual by donating $10 to Food Bank For NYC. Membership to Mutual gives u access to other great perks from different stores in NYC!
by Peanut Butter & Co.
Pb&j milkshake is my favorite milkshake ever
Seriously obsessed with this place. I created my own toasted wheat sandwich with cinnamon peanut butter, bananas and fluff... So delish!
by Vanessa P.
Cute, talk-for-hours-friendly, and right by campus. Love the cinnamon peanut butter cream cheese apple sandwich!
by Kristina R.
Try one of their delicious sandwiches and save 10% off your meal when you donate through The Mutual. Mutual team favorites: The Elvis & Pregnant Lady.
by The Mutual
Cookie dough surprise was very tasty. Went well with a grape soda.
If you're a huge PB fan and it's nearby, it might be worth at try, but the sandwiches aren't particularly creative and don't use any better ingredients than you'd get at most grocery stores.
by Omer Z.
Elvis! Bacon. Yes, please.
by Marcus C.
The best comfort food in Manhattan. Crusts off and a crazy straw, please!
by Melissa P.
Elvis is way too heavy (the sandwich)... Best part is the bacon that costs extra. Skip it!
by david ' dj shakez ' t.
Get the Elvis & pay the extra buck for the bacon.
by Jillana B.
Maple peanut butter & bacon on wheat toast. Doesn't get much better than that! (4 of 4 petals via Fondu)
by Frank R.
by Stacy S.
Get the Elvis with bacon so you don't live your life wondering "what if"
by Jake S.
The Elvis was great...dont even think about dieting (3 of 4 petals via Fondu)
by Laticia F.
Great staff and great sandwiches!
by Kaitlin L.
I love the cherry cheesecake sandwich- cherry preserves, cream cheese, crunchy PB on toasted white bread. It was the 'sandwich of the week' at one time, but I ask for it each time I visit! Delish!!!
by Ariel E.
Try the Elvis - Crunchy peanut butter, bananas and bacon! (via @Foodspotting)
by Nicole M.
Always my favorite place for dessert. Peanut butter pie = heaven on a plate.
by Barrie C.
Definetely try the egg cream there in chocolate! It's amazing!
Get the chocolate peanut butter pie! It's bomb!
by Michelle W.
Hop-off at Stop #7 & try The Elvis! Buy a sandwich & show your Gray Line New York ticket at checkout to receive a FREE jar of peanut butter. Offer valid in shop only between December 5-16, 2011.
by Gray Line New York
Have the Elvis sandwich. It's out of this world!
by Maribel L.
But yourself a jar of smooth operator and bring the goodness home with you!
by Nicole H.
Eat the PB Bliss sundae, so gooooood :)
by Anders M.
This place is super cute and yummy! Just make sure you get a glass of milk to wash it down:)
by Allison C.
If you love peanut butter sandwiches, this is the place for you. Tons of crazy yet delicious combinations. Try the "Elvis" - grilled with peanut butter, banana, honey, and bacon!
by New York Habitat
Try the peanut-butter & fluff, or the Elvis (PB with banana and honey)
by Kevin S.
Try the Elvis Peanut Butter Sandwich - Bananas, honey, peanut butter, and bacon - perfect combo (via @Foodspotting)
by David B.
Simply the greatest shop in the world!
by Dave C.
New York Foodie Blogs
Do you blog about dining in New York?
Share your opinions with Foodio54 users and get extra exposure to your blog!
Third Rail Coffee
240 Sullivan Street
241 Sullivan St Cafe Shop Shade
241 Sullivan Street W 3rd Street
227 Sullivan Street
218 Sullivan Street
82 West 3rd Street
86 West 3rd Street
119 Macdougal Street
117 Macdougal Street
80 West 3rd Street
123 Macdougal Street