> >


Portobello Cafe



4221 Hylan Boulevard
Staten Island, NY 10308

View more Staten Island restaurants

(718) 356-2233

Cuisine: Cafes, Italian Restaurants


4.9 of 5.0 from 204 reviews

Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free


Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY
  • Portobello Cafe in Staten Island, NY

Portobello Cafe Reviews

Add your review for Portobello Cafe.

  • Mike GGreat service. We will be back.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good. Food was excellent

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent great food and a great waitress

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GI think everything was great

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe food was fantastic and the service was great. The entire staff was very attentive throughout the entire meal.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GAlways a pleasant experience when we come here! Excellent service & delicious food!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GFood was excellent and so was the service. Fish was cooked perfectly

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GGreat service. Very personable

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWonderfull. The service was excellent and the food was delicious.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GSpecials should be available to large groups

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent , waiter was courteous and food was excellent!!!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GOur waiter Mauricio was very attentive and respectful of our dinner time. This was the first time I dined here and overall I am pleased with the service and courtesy of the staff. My date and I ...

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExperience was great as usual. Alyssa our waitress was wonderful. Food was amazing along with the dessert

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent food with even better service! We've been coming here for years! One of our favorite restaurants!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery attentive service bad the food was exceptional

    33333 by Mike G


  • Mike GService was excellent from the host to the manager. Kevinwas very friendly and helpful. The food was good, but not as excellent as it usually is.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExperience was wonderful. Alyssa was perfect!,,,

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWonderful as always!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GGreat! Very attentive server.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GEverything was delicious!!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GOverall wonderful experience. Our waitress was absolutely wonderful

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GGood as always

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good service. Food was excellent

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GDelicious food as always great service!!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GBest service ever. Had the linguini and clams absolutely a must have

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe food was stupendous.. My server Kevin was superior ...

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe best chicken parmagiano ever.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good food and service

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good pork should be just a bit larger otherwise very goodBathroom needs a bit checking on

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWonderful can't wait to come back !

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GGreat food and great service

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GBoth the food and service were outstanding!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GJust great as usual

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GOur waiter CJ was attentive and pleasant. We had a great experience.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe service was excellent I appreciate the lengths that management and staff went to in order to make sure we had everything we needed. Great experience.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe service was wonderful and always asking what we like to have. Showed us how to look up everything. Very polite and courteous. The food was excellent. Our waiter was great, liked him very muc...

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GIt was great, food was delicious.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Heather Anne The atmosphere. Also request that your pasta be in a round dish unless you like eating pasta out of a cereal bowl.

    33333 by Heather Anne "Queen Organist I" P.


  • Mike GVery nice!!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GAs always, our experience was great. Great service and great food.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent. Perfect. Food was delicious. Service was incred.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWonderful. The food is always delicious, the service is always remarkable & the atmosphere is always pleasant.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GFood was great as always .. Nicole was amazing she was so nice and knew exactly what to recommend food and drink wise we couldn't have been happier she was amazing.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good, as always!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWe had a great meal and our server was excellent!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWe love dining at Portobello Cafe! The food is absolutely delicious. The servers are always friendly and accommodating. The sangria is to die for!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GService was excellent.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery nice service. I will definitely come back.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GService was great, food was great... Perfect, sexy date atmosphere.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GGreat !!! - from Lysper

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent service and food!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GFood and service was excellent.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GFood and service was excellent

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent. Alyssa was fantastic. Very attentive.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GThe waitress was amazing! The food was delicious. Truly great experience.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GService and food is great. 2nd time here celebrating our anniversary. Definitely coming back!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GWe enjoyed he food, the setting and the service.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GEverything was great as usual

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent food and service my wife and I come regularly and will continue to do so????.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GVery good.

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GI think it was delicious the food was perfect

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GExcellent!!!!

    55555 by Mike G


  • Mike GFood was excellent service was on point

    55555 by Mike G


  • Visit i.Jennifer M: It was excellent the waitress was very nice http://www.itruereview.com/portobello-cafe-2/

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Alyssa was extremely friendly and an outstanding waitress.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was great staff was friendly and kind. Great experience.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Wonderful.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Dining experience was great. The waiter was very accommodating with my diet needs. I will be back again for their Burgermeister day soon !

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.excellent food and great service!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Pretty good!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Had a wonderful dinner the staff was fantastic the food delicious

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was great! Along with the white sangria :) love the 2 for 1 deal!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Our waitress was so helpful and very friendly. Our meals were excelent and we will be back.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent from start to finish

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great waitress

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was terrific, service great. As always

    55555 by Visit i.


  • janine VThis place sucks ...they have so many rules the manager is a stupid stupid woman did not do anything to rectify the problems that I had today with my family..

    11111 by janine V


  • Visit i.Excellent time, excellent service, excellent food!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service was wonderful. Joey was very helpful and had great recommendations. The food was excellent.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.the food was AMAZING

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food, great service. Relaxing atmosphere for a quiet night out.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Waiter was very helpful answering our questionsServese was great and everyone very polite

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food, would recommend to all my friends and family to come here to eat.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food is delicious. Truly the best!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service was excellent today. We were not planing on coming back after our past two visits due to terrible service. Really glad we did.

    33333 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent food paired with great service!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food here is delicious. My friend and I really enjoyed it. It's even more wonderful that they offer specials. The service is great and everyone is friendly and very curtious . Will definite...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.everything was great

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Came with a few friends for dinner. Started with the Eggplant appetizer (DELISH!)????????! Loved the sauce. We also had the special mushroom strudel which was also great. For the main meal we ord...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Very good service and delicious food.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.our server Andréa was very sweet and well mannered also very attentive

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Very innovative using the IPAD for wine list & dessert menu. The staff was friendly and courteous.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Alyssa was a great waitress. We enjoyed the service very much and will definitely be back!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is my favorite restaurant. I've never experienced bad service. I always leave with money in my pocket and left overs for tomorrow's lunch.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was delicious, service was exceptional and white peach sangria is amazing. Always a great experience here.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Meal was outstanding. Great portions . We always enjoy coming here .

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This was our first time here and we will definitely be coming back. Our waitress Alyssa was very attentive, the food was excellent with huge portions, and the prices are great too. It is family f...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food is always great

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food and Nicole's service was efficient and friendly

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Absolutely love this restaurant For my daughter's 9th birthday she chose this restaurant because it's her favorite! Love it! Our waitress, Andrea, was wonderful!!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Amazing!!! The best food and drinks on this island!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Delicious food and great value! Always a hit...superb service too!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food was delicious and the service was excellent. The server was so gracious and.very attentive

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was great, waiters were perfect. Always a great time.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Another Delicious dinner and the service was wonderful! Thank you Alexa!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great deal, food and service!!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I think the food service and service is great. The wait staff and manager were very nice and made sure we were happy with everything.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Carol was friendly and the food was delicious! We came all the way from Long Island to celebrate Mother's Day for the second year in a row and it was sooooo worth it!! Great service and the rock ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We had a great dinner. Carol was a pleasure great service and so personable. She was great. Food was delicious

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Chef was great!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Jen, Mellisa and entire staff and food are all great!!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great service, great food and wonderful atmosphere. One of the bes spots on Staten Island.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Carol is the best! Love the atmosphere. They always have phenomenal dinner deals. Love the new after hours menu! Looking forward to coming back!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service was great and food was delicious what else could you ask for,, ? I'll be back,,

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Dinner was great service was impecable

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Fantastic service, food was delish, tortellini carbonara and sautéed chicken and artichoke pasta are top notch!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent service, good food at a good price. Staff very friendly

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Waiter was great. Melissa makes wonderful cosmopolitans. Food was not hot. Bathroom needed to be cleaned. Calamari appetizer was very tasty

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is my third time here! All three times Carol has been our waitress and she is AMAZING, The service is impeccable and the food Delicous. The red sauce is amazing which is very hard to find. ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is one of THE BEST Restaurants on the Island. I would never be embarrassed to bring any guests here and we come here as often as we are able. The staff is ALWAYS top notch. we love Carol!...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Carol was fantastic! Definitely coming again!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.First time here and it was delicious! Look forward to coming again...:)

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellant service. Loved our dinner, Cooked as we requested. The prix fix dinner was really a great deal.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service and food was excellent

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was delicious! Service was great, definitly a great excperience

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Love this place. Great service and food

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was delicious and the service was outstanding!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Delicious meal, great service, cozy and fun atmosphere! Definitely recommend esp for the 2 for 1 during the week.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was excellent. Service was excellent. Over all it was a great experience

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We had Frank as our waiter. He was very cordial and attentive. We had a special martini which was very tasty and a delicious sangria. We will come back again.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.As usual our meal was excellent!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food great atmosphere have been here several times

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent service... Delicious food

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great sevice , great food.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service and food was spectacular! Our first time to Portobello and will return!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Delicious food, great service. Could have better lighting in dining area.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Service was excellent, food (as always) delicious! It's so nice to have a great place in the neighborhood to stop in and have dinner that never disappoints!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Frank was an excellent server!!! We will definately be back!!!!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Absolutely WONDERFUL SERVICE! Very impressed with the staff and the food was AMAZING! We will definitely be coming back ??????

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. Service was perfect. Very attentive and helpful but not intrusive.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Nicole was awesome! She kept coming back to check on the food and see if we needed anything. Great server!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I had the cheddar stuffed pork chop with Apple chutney and sweet potatoes OMG JUST AD GOOD AS the last time. Meals are very consistent !!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We enjoyed our dinner very much. Loved the stuffed pork chop and salmon.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The service and food is always great!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great experience every time I come here. Love the specials and best cappuccino on SI. Manager Jen is a doll, and the wait staff is very helpful and know how to give great dining experience. Will ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The service and food is very exceptional. Good portions.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Everything was delicious. Service fantastic as always. Alyssa was very sweet.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I really enjoyed the cute decor and the food was delicious !

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Everything was great! Service, food, all!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food and service was excellent !

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I love the House Pasta. I get it every time I come. Just the right balance of everything I love.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Amazing service and food

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Love this restaurant! Come at least 4 times a month! Best Italian egg rolls and escargot!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent Restaurant! Food is great, service is exceptional!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Such am incredible experience every time we come! From service to taste the quality at this establishment has raised the bar for restaurants across the island. I would highly recommend the buy on...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Absolutely amazing saff and food great for families and date nighs!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food and service is great try the stuffed pork chop DELISH!!!!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This was my first time at Portobello Cafe. The food was delicious! We took advantage of the buy one get one and the portion size was perfect for a satisfied meal and left overs. The peanut butter...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Very excellent service and friendly employees. Delicious food. Very clean. Five stars!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Everything is always great!! Alyssa was very attentive! We will always be back,,

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent restaurant...delicious food... Perfect staff. Alyssa was very attentive to our needs.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great all around!!!!! A wonderful neighborhood restaurant ....

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.As always,food was delicious! Had a great time and meal.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food is amazing, the specials are great and I love the atmosphere

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The service was wonderful and friendly the food was delicios

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is one of our favorite go to restaurants for both us as a married couple and if we want to bring friends. The food is delicious , service is excellent, and the prices are very reasonable. W...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We've been coming here for 15 years & have never been disappointed. The food & service is always great. Always a great variety of food.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is our second time here.we enjoyed everything . Your staff is attentive ad friendly.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Always a good experience and you can't beat the two for one deal.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great service & great food!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was delicious and the ambience was super relaxing. Our waitress was attentive and courteous. Would definitely come back again.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We have had a delightful evening while being served by Donna. We've eaten hear before and will be back not just because the food has always been good but also for the relaxed no rush atmosphere. ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food. Big portions. Friendly service. Very accomadating

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food! Great service! Love coming to portobellos to eat. Delicious!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was great and so was service! Came for mother's birthday, had the buy one get one entree great deal! Very nice ambiance.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.As always, phenomenal

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Everything was great, The hostess was extremely nice, attentive, & well informed.Brought us to the table & had a lovely smile. The waiter was wonderful too.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We had a delicious dinner and great service given by Donna.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We had a wonderful experience here at Portobello Cafe. We plan to frequent this restaurant when we visit Staten Island again. Our meal was exceptional as well as the service. Keep up the great j...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Portobello Cafe is hands down my favorite restaurant on Staten Island. Amazing food, great staff. Never change!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food has always been so good . Service has always been excellent& friendly atmosphere.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We love it here! The food and service is great.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We love it here ... Sangria is wonderful and food is great ! Service is always good .

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Every thing was great as usual, Donna our waitress was exceptional, I would deftly come back

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellant - from iTrueReview

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This is one of my girlfriend's and I favorite places too eat. Food is amazing, service is so nice and friendly and the prices are unbeatable!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.This evenings as a very pleasant experience. The staff was pleasant and inviting the service was great and the food delicious!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food and service are always outstanding !!

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Excellent atmosphere with great friends. Suggest Frank as your service specialist

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We have been customers of Portobello cafe for many years and frequent your establishment practically as often as we go out, The food is always great and the service is excellent. The wait staff ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Food was fantastic and the service was great. Portions were large and price was fantastic.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Everything was terrific

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I love portobello cafe because the food is deliciously prepared with just the right am. Nount of seasoning. Not overly slty but using the right amount of herbs and seasonings the service is exce...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great food great service

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food is always delicious, the staff is wonderful! always a pleasure to eat here.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.We were extremely pleased with our dinner. Everything was cooked to perfection. We routinely frequent your establishment

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.Great service. The food was awesome from the appetizers to the dessert. Recommend it to everyone.

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.The food is amazing and priced very reasonably. Generous portions!The staff is extremely hospitable and eager to help. (Special thanks Donna, Jen,Jimmy,Andrew, Andréa,Laura). Love the weeknight ...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Visit i.I thought the food was fresh and had a great flavor we have been coming for a couple of years and I would definitely say the flavor always stays consistent evert time we come also the waiters an...

    55555 by Visit i.


  • Preston M.We came to eat here with my sister from Florida. We waited 45 minutes and to our chagrin they seated locals in front of us. Have never been treated this rudely before. Beware

    22222 by Preston M.


  • davidSeafood fra diavolo. Awesome - you wont be disappointed.

    55555 by david


  • Quintin A.The chicken parm is second to none

    55555 by Quintin A.


  • Kenrick L.Food is excellent!!!

    55555 by Kenrick L.


Map of Portobello Cafe

Restaurants similar to Portobello Cafe

Nearby Restaurants

Events in Staten Island