Looking for restaurants open on Thanksgiving or restaurants open on Christmas?

> >

Rosarito Fish Shack

168 Wythe Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211

View more Brooklyn restaurants

(718) 388-8833


  • Sunday: 11:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • Monday: 5:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • Tuesday: 5:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • Wednesday: 5:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • Thursday: 5:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • Friday: 5:00 am - 1:00 am
  • Saturday: 11:00 am - 1:00 am

Cuisine: Mexican Restaurants, Seafood Restaurants

4.6 of 5.0 from 167 reviews

price range:$26 to $50


Write a Review

Is this your restaurant?
Claim Your Listing For Free

Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY
  • Rosarito Fish Shack in Brooklyn, NY

Rosarito Fish Shack Reviews

Add your review for Rosarito Fish Shack.

  • Ramlah BoadiFish and Chicken tacos!

    55555 by Ramlah Boadi

  • Gabrielle S.Very cozy place, nice atmosphere, a bit pricey though.

    55555 by Gabrielle S.

  • Ishe CI am Mexican. The fried fish tacos are Fantastic. Also, the 4 Leches Cake is fresh, perfectly consistent, and had an amazing flavor. By far one the best 4 leches I have had in my life!

    55555 by Ishe C

  • Ryan aCarne Asana is excellent

    55555 by Ryan a

  • Good SMagnificent food! Great staff! Hip area.

    55555 by Good S

  • Jean T.Go there for the happy hour oysters and house margarita

    55555 by Jean T.

  • Bora C.Best oysters (East Coast). Best ceviche (Peruvian). Best fish tacos (pescado). Taste explosions all around.

    55555 by Bora C.

  • Hayden DCeviche, hamachi

    55555 by Hayden D

  • IrinaLovely place for a brunch with authentic feel. Try raw fish tacos, ceviche and black mushroom quesadilla

    55555 by Irina

  • Elysia M.Randomly have great bartenders that'll make you cool drinks if you ask nicely

    55555 by Elysia M.

  • Brighty CThe Lobster Tacos were great!

    55555 by Brighty C

  • Alexandra W.Brunch ceviche was excellent. If ordering margaritas, skip the agave for a less sweet cocktail.

    55555 by Alexandra W.

  • DebbieTacos are way overpriced. Guac lacks flavor. But the ceviche is decent.

    33333 by Debbie

  • İpek A.The worst sangria that i've ever had...

    22222 by İpek A.

  • Ashley M.Some of the worst service ever received in NYC. Lobster roll and driest are good but not with the time investment in waiting. Drinks came after our meal. Better places in Williamsburg.

    22222 by Ashley M.

  • Giovanni D.This is a solid choice for fish in the Brooklyn area. The lobster tacos were pretty good.

    55555 by Giovanni D.

  • Luc ATacos were a little expensive but filled with lots of fish and other delicious content

    55555 by Luc A

  • Chris B.Tacos, quesadillas, and the guac.

    55555 by Chris B.

  • Gretta TGood for happy hour outside seating and chips. Tacos are alright

    55555 by Gretta T

  • Adam MaySick fish tacos

    33333 by Adam May

  • Wade B.Happy hour oysters

    55555 by Wade B.

  • Jay E.Mexican food and cocktails. Tacos and atmosphere were great. Service was solid.

    55555 by Jay E.

  • Byron W.Admittedly I did not eat the food here, but would gladly come back. The building itself appears to be quite old, and much of it has been left the same. Some newer re-modeling on the ceiling.

    33333 by Byron W.

  • Alex PyatetskyEverything here is good. Awesome date interior. Taco Tuesday = sacrament. I hate myself every Wednesday after forgetting taco Tuesday. A+++

    55555 by Alex Pyatetsky

  • AndreyВсе наисвежайшее! Пригодно для ночного тусняка. Велкам

    55555 by Andrey

  • Andrea B.Really good food but I find it a bit overpriced. Location and ambiance are def a plus.

    55555 by Andrea B.

  • The LIQ NY KHappy Hour margaritas are THE best!!!!

    55555 by The LIQ NY K

  • Cameron M.3 plates of tacos, 2 margaritas, 1 table outdoors. You have yourself a fine start to the evening.

    33333 by Cameron M.

  • Emily SPan seared fish tacos are pretty good, although it'd be nice if they gave you 3 instead of only 2

    33333 by Emily S

  • JessicaRabbitFish filet w/blackened Kale❤️

    55555 by JessicaRabbit

  • Ina LiTacos are pretty small $10 but try their Chorizo Mussels ($13), avocado salad, and quinoa side

    55555 by Ina Li

  • Daria DDelicious fish tacos, beautiful music and on the whole amazng relaxing and friendly vibe. Strongly recommended!

    55555 by Daria D

  • Veronika AWaiter forgot to order appetizer, we got our main dish before that. We were sitting with dirty plaits on our table for 15 minutes. Dish is very- very small. Ordered couple of ceviches- very small.

    22222 by Veronika A

  • Tom M.Tuesday is taco night

    55555 by Tom M.

  • Lucía DExcelente atención y la comida es de otro nivel.

    55555 by Lucía D

  • Rob B.The Pescado and Sake Tacos were on point. The Calamari was also tasty.

    55555 by Rob B.

  • Juno LMargaritas and fish tacos a must

    55555 by Juno L

  • Juno LFish tacos and margaritas for happy hour -- tequila selection is tops

    55555 by Juno L

  • Todd SlaterAmazing tequila menu, fabulous tacos (especially fish) - decent ceviche-- come for half price happy hour 4-7pm

    55555 by Todd Slater

  • Raquelle Jessiemussels w. chorizo, fish tacos, guac n chips, corn on the cob SOLID

    55555 by Raquelle Jessie

  • Brittani TNice outdoor seating. Ceviche is very small portions.

    55555 by Brittani T

  • Rafael B.Отвратительные латино американские хипстеры...

    55555 by Rafael B.

  • Gordon MeiThe huitlacoche and pescado tacos are solid.

    55555 by Gordon Mei

  • EduardService is very slow.

    33333 by Eduard

  • Kimberley S.Carnitas tacos!!!

    55555 by Kimberley S.

  • Melissa R.Wonderful tequila and late night salmon ceviche.

    55555 by Melissa R.

  • Leah L.Yummy red wine sangria! The Seafood platter for 2 isn't very filling though. I regret not ordering tacos!

    55555 by Leah L.

  • Dan ChanMicheladas and fried fish tacos.

    55555 by Dan Chan

  • Amy T.2 for 1 happy hours on margaritas? Sign me up.

    55555 by Amy T.

  • Maria A.Carne Asada Heaven.. Great causal dining spot.

    55555 by Maria A.

  • Nathan MusgroveFish tacos!

    55555 by Nathan Musgrove

  • Christopher L.Huitlacoche quesadilla is bada$$. Get up ON that.

    55555 by Christopher L.

  • SU KayaTry tacos!! they are delicious.

    55555 by SU Kaya

  • Gregory D.Overrated. The octopus hot dog is good, the peruvian ceviche is mediocre, pricey; average service but very nice decor

    55555 by Gregory D.

  • Becksdiva B.I'm in love with this place!!! Just had my birthday brunch here and all of my guest said this is a place they have to visit again!!! Great staff!!! Have the corn!!!

    55555 by Becksdiva B.

  • Margot M.You guys happy hour has FIVE dollar margaritas. Dont mind if I dooooo

    55555 by Margot M.

  • Andrea B.Neighborhood favorite for good fresh food. Everything I've had has been great.

    55555 by Andrea B.

  • Kathleen S.the service was horrible and the food was mediocre. cozy little spot with cute decor but really that is the only appealing thing about this place. way better spots around this area for the same price

    33333 by Kathleen S.

  • Kevin S.Great atmosphere for a fun dinner spot. Arrive early for half priced margaritas and $1.25 chef's choice oysters. Great crispy fish tacos.

    55555 by Kevin S.

  • Caitlyn K.Red sangria + fish tacos + corn on the cob = perfection! Don't miss this awesome seafood/Mexican hybrid!

    55555 by Caitlyn K.

  • Megan LangstonThe mezcal margarita is awesome!

    55555 by Megan Langston

  • Cristina$5 margaritas a $ 3 beers on a Saturday? It's on! Super cheap and cute place.

    55555 by Cristina

  • Caitlin C.The fish tacos are great.

    55555 by Caitlin C.

  • TreyFish tacos, guac and a rita. Perfect.

    55555 by Trey

  • Kev S.Ceviche ceviche ceviche. Stick to that and raw bar.

    55555 by Kev S.

  • Gabrielle G.Hotdog de Pulpo 💜💜💜

    55555 by Gabrielle G.

  • Sebastián Behar PiqueroOctopus hot dog!

    55555 by Sebastián Behar Piquero

  • Nikki BogopolskayaWhat's good here? As the name may suggest; the fish. Get ceviche, fish tacos and oysters, and snag a table outside.

    55555 by Nikki Bogopolskaya

  • Jordan CrookThis is my regular spot. Best fried fish tacos in all of life.

    55555 by Jordan Crook

  • NicholeGood for late night dining.

    55555 by Nichole

  • Chet M.Fantastic tacos. Grab a bite outside before walking over to East River Park.

    55555 by Chet M.

  • Phellyp SantosLugar ótimo para estar com os amigos!

    55555 by Phellyp Santos

  • Amadou CrookesGet the mushroom quesadilla!

    55555 by Amadou Crookes

  • Kim J.The oysters are always fresh, and the lobster tacos are all kinds of delicious.

    55555 by Kim J.

  • Kyle K.Margheritas are a little on the sour side, great happy hour prices tho.

    55555 by Kyle K.

  • Ione RangelComida ótima! No verão sente do lado de fora e aproveite!

    55555 by Ione Rangel

  • Ramez K.Overpriced tourist trap. Just go for drinks.

    22222 by Ramez K.

  • Thiago N.Go for pulpo hot dog!

    55555 by Thiago N.

  • Alexis D.Good margs.

    55555 by Alexis D.

  • Sarah S.While the food is great, the service is terrible.

    33333 by Sarah S.

  • Olivier S.OK. But service is too slow...

    33333 by Olivier S.

  • Megan ConahanGreat service and fish tacos. Skip the margaritas

    55555 by Megan Conahan

  • Shivone G.Was not acknowledged for a good 20 min after arriving, so yeah eff this place.

    11111 by Shivone G.

  • Mindy L.I usually love this place, but the one female bartender needs to check her attitude.

    33333 by Mindy L.

  • Luca G.Overpriced, unbeliveble small portion, service so slow. Terrible experience

    11111 by Luca G.

  • cecilia p.Have the linguini with clams. So good.

    55555 by cecilia p.

  • Nick O.Taco Pescado FTW

    55555 by Nick O.

  • Daniel SThe very best ceviche in town. Try the sampler together with a chardonnay. Lobster with strawberries tapa quite original. Decoration is superb, relaxed and different to what expected. A+ !

    55555 by Daniel S

  • Amanda FoleyReally fantastic service here...or, it could just be the fact that I'm so excited about friendly American waiters when I'm used to surly London service. Tacos are fab.

    55555 by Amanda Foley

  • Chantae V.Rosandia cocktail is soooo delicious! Just the right amount of spice. Also, you must try the Toro starter...to die for!!!

    55555 by Chantae V.

  • David H.Walked by it a few times, was really crowded. Stopped yesterday for brunch w/the Mrs it was amazeballs. Happy hour starts at 11am, I wanted everything on the menu. Best time is durning the week.

    55555 by David H.

  • Roman B.Fish tacos are a must (crispy tilapia)

    55555 by Roman B.

  • Veronica G.Degustação de ceviches muito boa. Mas o de atum é incrível!

    55555 by Veronica G.

  • Sarah PHappy Hour from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. >> it's more like "Happy Day"!

    55555 by Sarah P

  • Lily P.Bad service.

    22222 by Lily P.

  • քℴuքée® MFirst and for most the atmosphere is awesome. Reggae music, chillin' is absolute. Snacks: guacamole & lobster roll are top! Tacos: pescado w/ crispy tilapia tastes beautifully. Prices are amazing!

    55555 by քℴuքée® M

  • Mahesh P.Avocado /black bean /skirt steak sandwich

    55555 by Mahesh P.

  • Mahesh P.Gruner Veltliner

    55555 by Mahesh P.

  • Justin P.Fish Tacos are great.

    55555 by Justin P.

  • Alex B.Better than La Esquina? It's very close. Get the fish tacos and decide for yourself.

    55555 by Alex B.

  • Grace S.Guacamole, calamari, and pescado tacos were the bomb. Shrimp empanadas were kinda gummy. If you like Mezcal, the Sabrosa cocktail was good.

    55555 by Grace S.

  • Joe M.Corn on cob absolute must

    55555 by Joe M.

  • Chanequa Mercedes P.Sunday brunch with cocktails cannot be beat. Great vibe and good food.

    55555 by Chanequa Mercedes P.

  • Steve F.For a place called "Fish Shack", the brunch menu is really lacking in fish.

    33333 by Steve F.

  • Adam E.The lobster tacos are a waste of money.

    22222 by Adam E.

  • Frederik TQuite busy on Sat night (of course) but still great food. Skirt steak was great.

    55555 by Frederik T

  • Peter N.Best Mexican in this end of Brooklyn

    55555 by Peter N.

  • Rafaela PBest ceviche ever! For desert the "tres leches" was amazing!

    55555 by Rafaela P

  • Michael G.Taco Tuesdays according to Jay is the jam

    55555 by Michael G.

  • Jennifer-jo M.The French fries are amazingly good. Maybe the best thing on the menu.

    55555 by Jennifer-jo M.

  • Elizabeth P.Nice atmosphere, but the food is overpriced for what you get, though tasty.

    33333 by Elizabeth P.

  • John R.The riazul is the drink to get

    33333 by John R.

  • Tom M.Here's a perfect lunch for you: Pescado Tacos--Crispy tilapia, Chile de Arbol, Chipolte Slaw, guacamole--with side of rice & beans and the 2 for 1 happy hour drinks.

    55555 by Tom M.

  • Nina N.$3 drafts (excellent selection) on Magic Monday nights - very legit. Food is pretty good.

    55555 by Nina N.

  • Nicole V.The best guacamole I've ever eaten!

    55555 by Nicole V.

  • Abby C.The hostess, Phoebe is awesome!!

    55555 by Abby C.

  • Rosarito BStarting 1/21/13 "Not Just Another Manic Monday"- Cure the Monday Blues and Join us for $3 Draught Beers All Night Long, oh yeah let the week begin the right way

    55555 by Rosarito B

  • Pablo G.Great for brunch!

    55555 by Pablo G.

  • Mike F.At night it's like something out of a Stefon sketch. This bar has everything; blow up dolls, 80s music, an upside down deer head, Jim Henson's Labyrinth on a projector...

    55555 by Mike F.

  • Edward TDon't come starving, it's taking more than 30 minutes to get your Tacos served. This is ridiculous .

    33333 by Edward T

  • Ed C.The Pulpo tacos are legit (cooked 3 times), everyone likes working here, and the owner Martin bought me a glass of wine. Good spot.

    55555 by Ed C.

  • Melanie T.Get the octopus salad!

    55555 by Melanie T.

  • Cesar P.The Shack Stew is everything to me.

    55555 by Cesar P.

  • Vanessa M.Two for one sangria on saturday.

    55555 by Vanessa M.

  • Matt H.Octopus tacos were pretty good... Straight-up fried fish taco was awesome. Get sides if you intend to fill up.

    55555 by Matt H.

  • Meaghan ButtonFood here is really great. Can't go wrong with any of the taco choices. Very fresh. Great happy hour too.

    55555 by Meaghan Button

  • Claire S.Very tasty, but overpriced for the portion size (and considering it's called a "shack")

    33333 by Claire S.

  • Oliver B.The Shack Stew is ridiculously good.

    55555 by Oliver B.

  • David L.Excellence selection of mescal, high-quality cocktails, excellent food. Try the lobster ceviche ( served with strawberries ) (4 of 4 petals via Fondu)

    55555 by David L.

  • Mahesh P.The special - whatever it is. Seriously...

    33333 by Mahesh P.

  • Mahesh P.Cocktails are *very* underrated...

    55555 by Mahesh P.

  • Inaki O.Riazul tequila is the bomb!!

    55555 by Inaki O.

  • Inaki O.Riazul best Tequila in the house!!

    55555 by Inaki O.

  • Mahesh P.The octopus dog is wierd looking, but brilliant.....

    55555 by Mahesh P.

  • Dan S.Come back in 2008 and enjoy this place when it was the Williamsburg Cafe

    55555 by Dan S.

  • Chanequa Mercedes P.Get a table in the front window for some great people watching.

    55555 by Chanequa Mercedes P.

  • Chanequa Mercedes P.Try the Sunday brunch menu. Everything is fresh and fantastic.

    55555 by Chanequa Mercedes P.

  • Veronica C.On Saturdays- the best party in wburg!

    55555 by Veronica C.

  • hugo l.Try the cheesalicious corn-on-the-cob!

    55555 by hugo l.

  • Melissa MHave Javier make you a couple of his famous margaritas, then say "Rosarito Fish Shack" 7 times real fast!

    55555 by Melissa M

  • Drew M.Love this place, lobster tacos are great, good ceviche

    55555 by Drew M.

  • Talis MShort rib tacos

    55555 by Talis M

  • Mahesh P.The specials, whatever they are...

    33333 by Mahesh P.

  • Dan S.Warning: Bloody Mary cost you $11! Food was good though.

    33333 by Dan S.

  • Lori W.Strawberry ginger drink. On point.

    55555 by Lori W.

  • Michelle L.Pulpo (octopus) Tacos will rock your world!! Fetuccini con congrejo (Crab) ... drinks are made w fresh produce... tequilla never tasted so good and good for u!

    55555 by Michelle L.

  • Sarah L.pulpo tacos..chile relleno..spicy marg and whatever the special is

    55555 by Sarah L.

  • enrique m.Read my leaps ....."get the pulpo hot dog " and tell me what do you think

    33333 by enrique m.

  • Veronique L.Not allowed to take pictures...of their fish bar

    33333 by Veronique L.

  • Christina D.Pulpo taco's with chorizo are out of this world!!

    55555 by Christina D.

  • Annie C.If you like crab, try the crab taquitos and crab fettucine. Yum! They totally won my heart :)

    55555 by Annie C.

  • Veronica C.The crab tacos and the octopus hot dog are amazing! :)

    55555 by Veronica C.

  • Bianca LShrimp tacos and pescadilla.

    55555 by Bianca L

  • Heather F.Great atmosphere- potato gratin side is yummy! Enchilada wasnt anything special but I look fwd to trying more food - cocktails are great! Not too sweet and spicy if u like.

    55555 by Heather F.

  • Leyla Y.Get the ceviche sampler and order an extra scallop ceviche, delicious!

    55555 by Leyla Y.

  • Pamela C.Try the pulpo tacos!!!! Out of control.

    55555 by Pamela C.

  • jonathan b.The pulpo tacos are out of control. I dare you to eat fewer than 10 of them.

    55555 by jonathan b.

  • sarah v.scallop ceviche were one of the best ones i've had!

    55555 by sarah v.

  • Stephen M.The bacon-wrapped octopus 'hot dog' with spicy cole slaw is brilliant...

    55555 by Stephen M.

  • Amalia H.Was so excited for Rosarito to open. Turned out more like red lobster :/ May go back in a couple of months when they have their sea legs.

    33333 by Amalia H.

  • Zack W.This place is DOPE. Seafood enchilada with rice and beans!

    55555 by Zack W.

  • Sarah ZNot bad. The guacamole was great and the mezcal cocktail was refreshing.

    55555 by Sarah Z

  • Lucy S.There aren't enough characters to describe all the things that went wrong when we ate there. And the food isn't good. Don't waste your time.

    22222 by Lucy S.

  • Richard B.Amazing guacamole

    55555 by Richard B.

  • Roberto P.Ceviche sampler with a dark beer, BOOM

    55555 by Roberto P.

  • Mike DGo to Mole or Taco Chulo instead.

    55555 by Mike D

  • Bonnie BThe poblano-potato gratin is sooooo good

    55555 by Bonnie B

Map of Rosarito Fish Shack

Restaurants similar to Rosarito Fish Shack

Nearby Restaurants

Events in Brooklyn